Getting Physical on Cigarettes - Smoking Cessation & Relapse Prevention

Overview

Adult female smokers will participate in an exercise-aided smoking cessation program, and will then be randomized into one of four cessation maintenance conditions: (a) Exercise Maintenance only (b) Exercise Maintenance + Relapse Prevention Booklets(c) Relapse Prevention Booklets + Contact and (d) Contact Control. Primary follow-up outcome is smoking behaviour. Secondary outcomes include exercise behaviour, Physiological measures (body composition (Dual-emission X-ray absorptiometry; DXA), vascular health (stiffness, endothelial function, carotid plaque volume), physical fitness), and Psychological measures (self-regulatory cognitions related to exercise adherence \[exercise, scheduling, barrier, relapse, and concurrent self-regulatory self-efficacy\]). The hypotheses detailed below are specific to the randomization of participants into the following 4 groups: 1. Exercise Maintenance only 2. Exercise Maintenance + Relapse Prevention Booklets 3. Relapse Prevention Booklets + Contact 4. Contact Control Hypothesis 1: Compared to quitters in the contact control condition, quitters exposed to a home-based lifestyle exercise maintenance intervention (Exercise Maintenance only and Exercise Maintenance + Relapse Prevention Booklets) will demonstrate significantly greater exercise adherence and fitness levels, as well as significantly less weight gain and smoking relapse rates following exercise-aided smoking cessation program termination. Hypothesis 2: Compared to quitters in the contact control condition, quitters exposed to relapse information only (Relapse Prevention Booklets + Contact) will experience significantly less smoking relapse following exercise-aided smoking cessation program termination. Due to the novelty and exploratory nature of the respective prevention programs, no hypotheses are specified with respect to which prevention program (exercise maintenance or relapse prevention information) will be superior to the other, or whether the additive benefits (i.e., exercise maintenance plus relapse prevention information) will be superior to one prevention program alone.

Adding exercise to cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) has been shown to aid smoking cessation and lessen some of the negative consequences of withdrawal symptoms (Marcus et al., 1999; Ussher, 2005). Recently, Prapavessis and colleagues (2007) demonstrated that their 12-week program, consisting of supervised vigorous intensity exercise as an adjunct to nicotine replacement therapy (NRT), facilitates smoking cessation, improves physical fitness, and delays weight gain in women smokers. However, a smoking relapse effect was shown post-intervention, illustrating a trend where, as abstinence decreased, physical fitness showed a corresponding decrease and an increase in weight (also see, Marcus et al.). These results suggest that exercise needs to be maintained if it is to be an effective aid to smoking cessation. In practice, long-term supervised and structured vigorous exercise regimes are beyond the scope of smoking cessation services. Therefore, it is important to determine whether an exercise intervention program can be developed to maintain weight and physical fitness after program termination, and thus prevent (or reduce) smoking relapse. Teaching smokers the necessary self-regulatory skills needed to abstain from smoking and adhere to exercise independently may be a promising avenue through which to ensure lasting health behaviour changes. The Getting Physical on Cigarettes program will begin in January 2010. The main purpose of this project is to examine whether an inexpensive, home-based lifestyle exercise maintenance intervention can demonstrate sustained health benefits in terms of weight gain and physical fitness benefits following an exercise and Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT) aided smoking cessation program. In addition, this trial seeks to examine previously unexplored topics of interest in the smoking abstinence literature; specifically, we are interested in whether the nicotine metabolite ratio (3-HC/Cotinine: Schnoll et al., 2009) is a useful biomarker for determining cessation success in relation to exercise and Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT) treatment, and whether the interactive effects of exercise and smoking cessation improve vascular health and lung function. Four hundred and twenty adult female smokers will follow a structured and supervised 14 week exercise-aided smoking cessation program, with the 10 week NRT program beginning at week 4. Participants will be randomized into one of four conditions: a) Exercise Maintenance; b) Exercise Maintenance + Relapse Prevention Booklets; c) Relapse Prevention Booklets + Contact; and d) Contact Control. Starting at week 8, women in the Exercise Maintenance conditions will engage in Group-Mediated Cognitive Behavioural (GMCB) therapy related to maintaining exercise in their home environment, while women in the Contact conditions will partake in group mediated discussions related to other health issues. The "Forever Free" smoking replase prevention book series (Brandon, Collins, Juliano, \& Lazev, 2000) will be distributed to participants in the Relapse Prevention Booklets conditions; however, all groups will receive the same amount of supervised exercise sessions and NRT. Following the termination of the 14 week intervention all participants will be contacted by a trained facilitator, who will deliver 15 minute biweekly (for the first month), monthly (for the next 2 months), and then bimonthly (for last 8 months) intervention strategies over the phone to continue to counsel the women according to her particular group-mediated condition. Primary end points (i.e., smoking abstinence) will be assessed weekly throughout the 14 week program and through follow-ups at 3, 6, and 12 months. Secondary end points (i.e., fitness, vascular health \[e.g., endothelial function, carotid plaque volume\], lung function, weight and self-regulatory cognitions) will be assessed at baseline and at week 14 as well as at 12 months. Accelerometers (ACTICALÒ) will be used to obtain an objective measure of physical activity at baseline, week 15 (1 week after the 14 week intervention) and at 6 and 12 months. The Getting Physical on Cigarettes trial will not only contribute to a better understanding of the role exercise plays as an aid to smoking cessation, but will also explore a means of increasing the cost-effectiveness of long-term smoking cessation programs. The findings resulting from this trial may have important implications for improving the quality of life among individuals who wish to stop smoking, which would, in turn, have a significant impact on the cost of health care to the Canadian public.