The overall objective of the CHANGE initiative is to change the delivery of care in primary care clinics to treat disease by reducing reliance on drugs and hospitals through the promotion of scientifically validated nutritional concepts and exercise. Specifically, the objective is to identify patients from primary care clinics with metabolic syndrome who are not morbidly obese and use diet and exercise interventions to reverse the changes, reduce reliance on pharmacotherapy and prevent progression to diabetes and cardiovascular disease.
Hypertension, cardiovascular disease, strokes, diabetes and their complications including renal failure and neuropathy are major contributors to healthcare costs1. Metabolic Syndrome, a widespread genetic trait refers to a group of factors that increase risk for these diseases. Progression of the components of the metabolic syndrome can be significantly reduced by dietary manipulation and exercise. The aging population, with both metabolic syndrome and muscular weakness, is going to result in an enormous social and financial burden not only for medical care but also for families caring for such patients. Existing knowledge would suggest that dietary modification and exercise training would substantially reduce the costs and complications of these medical conditions. The Canadian Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of cardiometabolic risk identify patients with metabolic syndrome who have an increased risk of cardiac and vascular disease and diabetes but the application of these results to prevent disease has been a dismal failure in general and in particular, in our country. The current model of advice about preventive care is through family doctors (FD) in the primary care setting. FDs tend not to advise their patients about diet and exercise for a variety of reasons including a lack of education about these modalities, a lack of support from professionals qualified to assess and advise about diet and exercise, the belief that drugs are better, lack of time and a lack of reimbursement in addition to patient barriers to adoption. Although other factors, such has smoking, hypercoagulability and increased expression of proinflammatory cytokines increase cardiometabolic risk, these changes are closely related to the metabolic syndrome. "Health behavior interventions" are identified as critical to preventing the occurrence of cardiovascular disease and diabetes. These interventions can be associated with appropriate pharmacotherapy where required. The guidelines recommend a multidisciplinary team to manage these interventions. In addition it is also recommended that ethnicity be considered in these interventions. The various traits associated with the metabolic syndrome are strongly influenced by genetic factors, i.e. the heritability of abdominal obesity and insulin resistance are estimated to be as high as 70%. Accordingly, the investigators propose to examine numerous genetic polymorphisms (also referred to as markers) that have been linked to the various traits associated with metabolic syndrome in a sub study. It is hypothesized that these markers can be used as a means to better predict the variable responses observed in individuals following a lifestyle intervention. Several companies have begun to commercialize direct-to-consumer genetic-testing to provide nutritional counseling to individuals based on the analysis of a small subset of polymorphisms11; however, there is an absence of scientific research to either support or refute the value of genetic markers for predicting an individual's response. Considering common genetic markers in a lifestyle intervention study will enable us to assess their value for predicting response.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
NA
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
NONE
Enrollment
305
Nutrition assessment, review of the basic principles of dietary intervention for metabolic syndrome with an emphasis on the clinical risk factors identified for each individual, joint goal setting to determine what dietary changes are feasible, considering intention and barriers to dietary behaviour change.
Exercise tests (aerobic fitness, muscular and flexibility tests) recommended by the Canadian Society of Exercise Physiology (CSEP), followed by an individualized exercise plan including fitness assessments.
Edmonton Oliver Primary Care Network
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Canadian Phase Onward Inc.
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Clinique de kinésiologie de l'Université Laval
Québec, Canada
Feasibility of the Diet Intervention
Percentage of the prescribed diet visits visits attended over 12 months. Each participant was to attend a total of 21 prescribed diet visits over 12 months.
Time frame: At 12 months
Feasibility of the Exercise Intervention
Percentage of the prescribed exercise visits attended over 12 months. Each participant was to attend a total of 21 prescribed exercise visits over 12 months.
Time frame: At 12 months
Number of Participants That Have Reversal of Metabolic Syndrome
Metabolic syndrome is defined as having 3/5 of the following: elevated blood pressure (or on medication), elevated blood sugars (or on medication), elevated triglycerides (or on medication), low HDL-C and a large waist circumference. Reversal of metabolic syndrome is defined as having less than 3/5 criteria
Time frame: At 12 months compared to baseline measures
Percentage of Participants With Improvements in at Least One Individual Components of Metabolic Syndrome
Improvements in blood pressure (or elimination of medication), blood sugars (or elimination of medication), triglycerides (or elimination of medication), HDL-C and waist circumference
Time frame: At 12 months compared to baseline
Change From Baseline in Diet Quality-Canadian Healthy Eating Index
Canadian Health Eating Index (HEI-C) is reported on a 100 point score with a higher score indicating a better outcome. A higher score means a better outcome. HEI-C is on a 100 point score.
Time frame: Change at 12 months compared to baseline
Change From Baseline in Diet Quality-Mediterranean Diet Score
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.
Mediterranean Diet Score (MDS) is reported on a 0-14 point score with a higher score indicating a better outcome.
Time frame: Change at 12 months compared to baseline
Change From Baseline in Aerobic Capacity
Estimated maximal oxygen consumption (VO2 max) standardized to age and sex
Time frame: Change at 12 months compared to baseline
Changes in Risk of Myocardial Infarction and Cardiac Events
Changes in PROCAM score, which estimates the risk of a myocardial infarction or dying from an acute coronary event within the next 10 years. Similar to Framingham risk score but for metabolic syndrome. A lower score means a better outcome. PROCAM score varies from 0-87,0 means there are no risk factors (pt is younger than 39), while 87 means the patient is a smoker and older than 60 years and presents all risk factors
Time frame: Change at 12 months compared to baseline
Changes in Continuous Metabolic Syndrome Risk Score
Metabolic syndrome risk score is a composite continuous score that measures the severity of metabolic syndrome as a continuous variable rather than dichotomized with arbitrary cut-points . The score is the principal component of waist circumference, glucose, systolic blood pressure, triglycerides. It has a mean of 0 and a standard deviation of 1 with higher score meaning greater risk. Reference Hillier TA, et al., Practical way to assess metabolic syndrome using a continuous score obtained from principal components analysis. Diabetologia (2006) 49:1528-1535
Time frame: Change at 12 months compared to baseline