First-Voided Urinary LH vs. GnRH-stimulation in Differentiating Slowly- From Rapidly Progressive-Precocious Puberty

Overview

Precocious puberty (PP) in girls is classically defined by the onset of secondary sexual characteristics before eight years of age, but subsequent pubertal maturation can be quite varied. In many girls, PP takes a rapid course of progression (rapidly progressive precocious puberty; RP-PP) with an early menarche and fusion of the epiphyseal growth plates, leading eventually to a reduced final height if not treated. In a subset of girls with PP however, the growth rate slows to normal for age, skeletal maturation progresses in accordance with chronological age and there is little to no risk of impairment of final height (slowly progressive precocious puberty; SP-PP). Other conditions of non-progressive PP include premature breast budding and unsustained PP that is characterized by a spontaneous regression of sexual precocity. Due to their benign course, slowly progressive (SP) PP and other non-progressive forms of PP do not warrant therapy with GnRH agonists. Differentiating these forms from RP-PP is therefore essential to prevent unnecessary intervention in a population that accounts for at least 50% of girls with PP. A distinction between these forms of PP may be difficult on clinical grounds however, since all these patients may present initially as isolated breast development. The gold standard for the diagnosis of true (central) PP is the measurement of gonadotropins following GnRH stimulation test. There is however an overlap between prepubertal and early pubertal values and between girls with premature breast budding and progressive PP. It was suggested therefore that progressive pubertal development and growth acceleration should be documented over a 3- to 6-months period before GnRHa therapy in initiated. More than a decade ago several studies demonstrated that urinary gonadotropins are age related and significantly increased during puberty. It has been suggested that urinary gonadotropins measurements can be used for differential diagnosis of pubertal disorders. This is based on the assumption that gradual elevation of nocturnal LH secretion prior to and at the onset of puberty can be reflected by first-voided urinary LH (ULH). In this prospective study, the investigators aimed to evaluate the value of first-voided ULH measurements in predicting pubertal course and differentiating SP-PP from RP-PP, by comparison to GnRH-stimulated gonadotropins.

Precocious puberty (PP) in girls is classically defined by the onset of secondary sexual characteristics before eight years of age, but subsequent pubertal maturation can be quite varied. In many girls, PP takes a rapid course of progression (rapidly progressive precocious puberty; RP-PP) with an early menarche and fusion of the epiphyseal growth plates, leading eventually to a reduced final height if not treated. In a subset of girls with PP however, the growth rate slows to normal for age, skeletal maturation progresses in accordance with chronological age and there is little to no risk of impairment of final height (slowly progressive precocious puberty; SP-PP). Other conditions of non-progressive PP include premature thelarche and unsustained PP that is characterized by a regression of sexual precocity. Due to their benign course, slowly progressive (SP) PP and other non-progressive forms of PP do not warrant therapy with GnRH agonists. Differentiating these forms from RP-PP is therefore essential to prevent unnecessary intervention in a population that accounts for at least 50% of girls with PP. A distinction between these forms of PP may be difficult on clinical grounds however, since all these patients may present initially as isolated breast development. The gold standard for the diagnosis of true (central) PP is the measurement of gonadotropins following GnRH stimulation test , where peak LH and peak LH/FSH ratio are the most valuable diagnostic parameters. There is however an overlap between prepubertal and early pubertal values and between girls with premature thelarche and progressive PP. It was suggested therefore that progressive pubertal development and growth acceleration should be documented over a 3- to 6-months period before GnRHa therapy in initiated. More than a decade ago, along with the development of high-sensitive immunoassay for gonadotropins that replaced the RIA, Demir and colleagues have shown that urinary gonadotropins are age related and significantly increased during puberty. It has been suggested by others that urinary gonadotropins measurements can be used for differential diagnosis of pubertal disorders. This is based on the assumption that gradual elevation of nocturnal LH secretion prior to and at the onset of puberty can be reflected by first-voided urinary LH (ULH). In this prospective study, the investigators aimed to evaluate the value of first-voided ULH measurements in predicting pubertal course and differentiating SP-PP from RP-PP, by comparison to GnRH-stimulated gonadotropins.