Comparison of Long-term Outcomes Following Endoscopic or Open Surgery for Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

Region Skane124 enrolled

Overview

No randomized trials have compared long-term outcomes following endoscopic and open carpal tunnel release in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS). The investigators conducted a single-center randomized controlled trial between January 1998 and December 2002, including 128 patients (25 to 60 years) with clinically diagnosed and electrophysiologically confirmed idiopathic CTS. The outcome measures included the validated CTS symptom severity and functional status scales completed at baseline and 1 year postoperatively. The trial showed that the 1-year outcomes of open and endoscopic carpal tunnel release regarding symptoms and function were equivalent. This extended follow-up of the randomized trial will primarily measure the symptom outcomes at 10-15 years after surgery. A questionnaire will be sent by mail to the patients. The questionnaire will consist of the CTS symptom severity and functional status scales, the 6-item CTS symptoms scale (CTS-6), the 11-item disabilities of the arm, shoulder and hand (QuickDASH), the 2-item palmar pain scale, and a visual analog scale about treatment satisfaction. The patients will also be asked about whether they had undergone further surgery for CTS in the same or contralateral hand after their operation in the randomized trial. The completed questionnaires will be scanned into a database. The scores for the different scales will be calculated. Analysis will include comparison between the open and endoscopic groups as well as within-group changes of scores from 1 year to 10-15 years.

Study Type

INTERVENTIONAL

Allocation

RANDOMIZED

Purpose

TREATMENT

Masking

NONE

Enrollment

124

Conditions

Carpal Tunnel Syndrome

Interventions

Endoscopic surgeryPROCEDURE

Surgery dwas done under local anesthesia injected at the portal sites only. Tourniquet was used. Each of the two skin incisions in the endoscopic procedure was 1 cm long. With the endoscope inserted from the distal portal and a hook knife inserted from the proximal portal, the transverse carpal ligament was divided from its distal edge to its proximal edge. Incisions were closed with non-absorbables sutures and a soft dressing was applied. Sutures were removed 10 days postoperatively.

Open surgeryPROCEDURE

Open carpal tunnel release using conventional open technique under local anesthesia and tourniquet. The incision in the open procedure extended from about 1 cm proximal to 3 cm distal to the wrist crease. The transverse carpal ligament was divided; no additional procedures were performed. a soft dressing was applied. Dressing and sutures were removed 10 days postoperatively.

Eligibility

Sex: ALLMin age: 25 YearsMax age: 60 Years

Medical Language ↔ Plain English

Inclusion Criteria (original trial): * Primary idiopathic carpal tunnel syndrome * age 25-60 years * currently employed * duration of symptoms of at least three months * inadequate response to six weeks' treatment with wrist splint * symptoms of classic or probable carpal tunnel syndrome according to the diagnostic criteria in the Katz hand diagram, and nerve conduction test showing median neuropathy at the wrist (distal motor latency ≥4.5 milliseconds, wrist-digit sensory latency ≥3.5 milliseconds, or sensory conduction velocity at the carpal tunnel segment \<40 metres/second but no other abnormalities. Exclusion Criteria (original trial): Inflammatory joint disease * diabetes mellitus, thyroid disorder, pregnancy, trauma to the affected hand during the preceding year * previous carpal tunnel release surgery in the affected hand * carpal tunnel release surgery in the contralateral hand during the preceding year * symptoms of carpal tunnel syndrome in the contralateral hand not adequately relieved by splint at the time of enrollment * current sick leave because of disorders other than carpal tunnel syndrome * inability to complete questionnaires because of language problem or cognitive disorder.

Outcomes

Primary Outcomes

Change in CTS symptom severity score

Time frame: Baseline to 10-15 years postoperatively

Secondary Outcomes

Rate of repeat surgery

Time frame: 10-15 years postoperatively

Change in CTS functional status score

Time frame: from baseline and 1 year to 10-15 years postoperatively

Residual pain in the scar or proximal palm

Time frame: 10-15 years postoperatively

Patient satisfaction with the results of surgery

Time frame: 10-15 years postoperatively

Change in CTS symptom severity score

Time frame: 1 year to 10-15 years postoperatively