This randomized pilot phase IV trial studies the side effects and how well varenicline works compared to nicotine replacement therapy in helping patients that smoke to quit. Varenicline is a drug that acts the same way as nicotine in the brain but is not habit-forming. Nicotine replacement therapy consists of nicotine patches and lozenges. It is not yet known if varenicline is more effective than nicotine replacement therapy in helping patients quit smoking.
Primary Objectives: To estimate (a) the effects at 12 weeks of either continuing on their current medication, switching to the other medication, or increasing the dose of their current medication among smokers initially treated with either varenicline 2 mg (VAR) or nicotine patch + ad lib lozenge (combined nicotine replacement therapy; CNRT) but who relapsed to smoking by week 6 of treatment, and (b) the effects of 12 weeks of continued treatment on either VAR or CNRT among individuals who are abstinent from smoking at 6 weeks. OUTLINE: Patients are randomized to 1 of 2 groups. GROUP I: Patients receive varenicline orally (PO) once daily (QD) or twice daily (BID), placebo patches QD, and placebo lozenges PO QD beginning on day 9 and continue for 6 weeks. Patients who are abstinent at week 6 will continue treatment for an additional 6 weeks. Patients who fail to achieve abstinence at week 6 are re-randomized to 6 additional weeks of therapy consisting of either continuing on the same treatment, switching to CNRT, or receiving high-dose varenicline. Patients also receive behavioral smoking cessation counseling consisting of 4 in-person visits, 4 phone visits, and 4 brief supportive phone calls lasting 10-15 minutes each over the 12 weeks of treatment. GROUP II: Patients receive placebo tablets PO QD or BID, nicotine patches QD, and nicotine lozenges PO QD beginning on day 9 and continue for 6 weeks. Patients who are abstinent at week 6 will continue treatment for an additional 6 weeks. Patients who fail to achieve abstinence at week 6 are re-randomized to 6 additional weeks of therapy consisting of either continuing on the same treatment, switching to varenicline, or receiving high-dose CNRT. Patients also receive behavioral smoking cessation counseling consisting of 4 in-person visits, 4 phone visits, and 4 brief supportive phone calls lasting 10-15 minutes each over the 12 weeks of treatment.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
DOUBLE
Enrollment
631
M D Anderson Cancer Center
Houston, Texas, United States
Seven-day point prevalence and treatment or treatment strategy
Estimated rates of seven-day point prevalence for varenicline and nicotine patch + lozenge at week 6 derive from meta-analyses.
Time frame: At week 6
Main effects of varenicline and nicotine patch + lozenge on smokers who remain on these medications throughout the trial as documented in questionnaires
Participants complete questionnaires about several topics including depression, mood, smoking behavior, and any effects from the study drug.
Time frame: Up to 12 weeks
Probability of response at week 12 conditional on response at week 6 and continuation of treatment
The probability of response at week 12 conditional on response at week 6 and continuation based on clinical consensus, taking into account the marginal rates of response at twelve weeks reported derived from meta-analysis. Monte Carlo simulations (K = 500) determined predictive power for the planned analyses.
Time frame: At 12 weeks
Probability of response at week 12 conditional on non-response at week 6 and continuation of treatment
The probability of response at week 12 conditional on non-response at week 6 and continuation of treatment based on clinical consensus, taking into account the marginal rates of response at twelve weeks reported derived from meta-analysis. Monte Carlo simulations (K = 500) determined predictive power for the planned analyses.
Time frame: At 12 weeks
Probability of response at week 12 conditional on non-response at week 6 and augmentation of treatment
The probability of response at week 12 conditional on non-response at week 6 and augmentation of treatment based on clinical consensus, taking into account the marginal rates of response at twelve weeks reported derived from meta-analysis. Monte Carlo simulations (K = 500) determined predictive power for the planned analyses.
Time frame: At 12 weeks
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.
Receive behavioral smoking cessation counseling
Given PO
Probability of response at week 12 conditional on non-response at week 6 and treatment switching
The probability of response at week 12 conditional on non-response at week 6 and treatment switching based on clinical consensus, taking into account the marginal rates of response at twelve weeks reported derived from meta-analysis. Monte Carlo simulations (K = 500) determined predictive power for the planned analyses.
Time frame: At 12 weeks
Probability that treatment continuation, switching, or augmentation confers benefit conditional upon failing to quit after the initial treatment with nicotine patch + lozenge for six weeks
Monte Carlo simulations (K = 500) determined predictive power for the planned analyses.
Time frame: 12 weeks
Probability that treatment continuation, switching, or augmentation confers benefit conditional upon failing to quit after initial treatment with varenicline for six weeks
Monte Carlo simulations (K = 500) determined predictive power for the planned analyses.
Time frame: 12 weeks