The Effectiveness of Neuromuscular Training in Healthy and ACL-Injured Adolescent Females

Overview

Recently, there has been a dramatic rise in the number of children participating in competitive sports. Adolescents involved in sports that require cutting, pivoting or body contact are at greatest risk for sustaining an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture of the knee, however, appropriate management remains controversial. The surgical technique is commonly performed in the adult population has been associated with risks for growth disturbance when performed on skeletally immature individuals. Therefore, the recommended standard of care in children is to initially follow a non-surgical management protocol that allows a patient to skeletally mature prior to ultimately receiving surgical reconstruction. Unfortunately, current non-surgical management protocols are ineffective at enhancing knee joint stability and dynamic function. There has been no research to indicate the most appropriate exercise program for the ACL deficient skeletally immature individual. A neuromuscular exercise program proven to be safe and effective in the ACL deficient adult population is perturbation training. In adolescents, research suggests neuromuscular exercises can reduce the rate of ACL injuries by 50%. However, currently there is no research investigating the benefits of a neuromuscular exercise on the management of a skeletally immature ACL-deficient individual. The results of this investigation will provide researchers and clinicians valuable information on the effect of neuromuscular perturbation exercises on knee joint stability and function immediately following injury. This has the potential to minimize the development of secondary meniscal tears and premature joint degeneration commonly demonstrated following an ACL injury.

Following ethics approval by the University of Manitoba and the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, 44 participants will be recruited for the study. During the intake session, subjects will complete informed and assent consent, participant information and knee demographic forms. A radiographic report of the knee confirming that the subject is skeletally immature will be obtained from the referring orthopedic surgeon or performed at the Pan Am clinic. For only the ACL-injured subjects, a clinical examination diagnosis and KT-1000 test will confirm the injury. Anthropometric data, such as age, height, weight, range of motion, leg circumference and the pubertal maturation observation scale (PMOS), will be collected. All subjects are required to pass the standardized screening protocol prior to continuing with the testing procedures. Testing Sessions: Each subject will participate in 4 follow-up test sessions after the initial intake; Pre-exercise session at the start of the study, Follow-up #1 at the mid-point of the study, Follow-up #2 at the end of the study and a Test-retest session during the no exercise phase of the study. Within the same week as completing the intake session, all subjects will complete the pre-exercise test session. All follow-up testing sessions will include: 1. Subjective evaluation of knee function via the Pedi-IKDC and Physical Activity Questionnaire for Children (PAQ-C), 2. Standardized warm-up on a stationary bike, 3. Dynamic balance evaluation using the SEBT and Y-Balance tests, 4. Strength testing using the Biodex isokinetic dynamometer and core stability tests, and 5. Knee laxity testing using the KT-1000. Both ACL-injured and healthy knee subjects will be randomly divided into two groups, Group A \& B. The week following baseline testing, Group A will begin the 5-week NMT protocol, complete a follow-up #1 testing session, then receive no intervention for 5 weeks, and return for a follow-up #2 testing session. The week following baseline testing, Group B will receive of no intervention for 5 weeks, then complete a follow-up #1 test session, complete the 5-week NMT protocol and then return for a follow-up #2 testing session. The test-retest session will be conducted during the first week of the "No Exercise" phase. Neuromuscular Training (NMT) Sessions: The established Neuromuscular Training (NMT) protocol is supervised, progressive program in which the patient maintains balance on three different support surfaces while a clinician administers purposeful manipulations of the support system.1 The patient maintains a single-leg stance on the rollerboard and tiltboard surfaces, and a two-leg stance with one foot on a roller board while the other is on a platform. Participants will complete two training sessions per week, for five weeks for a total of 10 training sessions. During each session, both legs will receive training for 2-3 sets of 1 minute duration on each of the support surfaces. Subjects will complete all training sessions with a Certified Athletic Therapist or Physiotherapist at the Pan Am clinic.