The purpose of this study is to determine whether auricular acupuncture (AA) according to the NADA protocol and progressive muscle relaxation (PMR) differ in their effectiveness of treating people with anxiety disorders or major depressive disorder. We hypothesized, that both treatments show significant effects in alleviating the examined items (tension, anxiety, anger/aggression and state ofr mood) and that there is no significant difference between these two treatments.
The purpose of this study is to determine whether auricular acupuncture according to the NADA protocol and progressive muscle relaxation differ in their effectiveness of treating people with anxiety disorders (AD) or major depressive disorder (MDD). In this study, acupuncture was executed according to the NADA protocol: a standardized and comparable method of auricular acupuncture (AA) with ease of application and limited adverse reactions, which seems to have high acceptance among psychiatric patients. The NADA (National Acupuncture Detoxification Association) protocol includes the needling of five specific acupuncture points on both ears. As a comparative relaxation treatment, progressive muscle relaxation (PMR) was applied in our study. It has been well established for many decades, especially for the treatment of severe states of physical and mental tension, which is a common symptom of anxiety disorders and depression. Many studies also suggest its potential utility in the treatment program of many other illnesses, which are associated with conditions of anxiety and depression, such as schizophrenia, sleeping disorders, endometriosis, atopic dermatitis or cancer. The main aim of this study was to examine the effectiveness of AA according to the NADA protocol versus PMR in patients with AD or MDD. We hypothesized, that both treatments show significant effects in alleviating the examined items (tension, anxiety, anger/aggression and state ofr mood) and that there is no significant difference between these two treatments. In order to increase the patients´ treatment acceptance and compliance, this study was set up in an open design in which each patient was freely able to choose between both treatments.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
NON_RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
NONE
Enrollment
136
Auricular acupuncture according to the the NADA protocol includes the needling of five specific acupuncture points on both ears: point 51 (= Sympathetic point), point 55 (= Shen Men), point 95 (= Kidney point), point 97 (= Liver point) and point 101 (= Lung point). All points were acupunctured with fine sterile single use steel needles with the size of 0.25 x 20 millimetres. The needles were inserted about 2-3 millimetres, so that the needle point pierces the skin and is just positioned in the cartilage of the ear. They remained in position for 30 minutes.
Progressive muscle relaxation was carried out by the method of Bernstein and Borkovec. All participants were asked to close eyes while sitting comfortably. Each group session included 16 main exercises of consciously tensing and relaxing specific groups of muscles.
Mean VAS scores of anxiety, tension, anger/aggression and mood before and after treatment within each treatment group at week 1.
VAS are rated as follows: ´tension´, ´anxiety´, ´anger/aggression´: VAS 0 = none, 100 = most imaginable; ´mood´: VAS 0 = bad, 100 = good.
Time frame: 1 week
Mean VAS scores of anxiety, tension, anger/aggression and mood before and after treatment within each treatment group at week 2.
VAS are rated as follows: ´tension´, ´anxiety´, ´anger/aggression´: VAS 0 = none, 100 = most imaginable; ´mood´: VAS 0 = bad, 100 = good.
Time frame: week 2
Mean VAS scores of anxiety, tension, anger/aggression and mood before and after treatment within each treatment group at week 3.
VAS are rated as follows: ´tension´, ´anxiety´, ´anger/aggression´: VAS 0 = none, 100 = most imaginable; ´mood´: VAS 0 = bad, 100 = good.
Time frame: week 3
Mean VAS scores of anxiety, tension, anger/aggression and mood before and after treatment within each treatment group at week 4.
VAS are rated as follows: ´tension´, ´anxiety´, ´anger/aggression´: VAS 0 = none, 100 = most imaginable; ´mood´: VAS 0 = bad, 100 = good.
Time frame: week 4
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.