Small Financial Incentives to Promote Smoking Cessation

Overview

The primary objectives of this study are 1) to evaluate the longer-term impact of an adjunctive, low-cost financial incentives intervention (relative to standard care) on smoking abstinence rates among socioeconomically disadvantaged individuals participating in a clinic-based smoking cessation program and 2) to identify treatment mechanisms and contextual factors associated with cessation outcomes among intervention participants using both traditional and ecological momentary assessment approaches. Those randomized to the financial incentives intervention will have the opportunity to earn small gift cards for biochemically-verified abstinence through 12 weeks post-quit. We hypothesize that individuals who are randomly assigned to the adjunctive CM intervention will have significantly higher rates of biochemically-verified abstinence at the 26-week post-quit follow-up than those assigned to Usual Care. In addition, we hypothesize that several factors related to socioeconomic disadvantage will be directly associated with non-abstinence, especially greater stress/adversity, limited psychosocial resources, greater negative affect, greater nicotine dependence, and poorer treatment adherence. The primary study endpoints will include self-reported tobacco use/abstinence, expired carbon monoxide (CO) levels (i.e., the amount of carbon monoxide present in an individual's breath when they breathe out), and saliva cotinine levels at 26 weeks post-quit attempt, though smoking status will be assessed at all visits. Traditional questionnaire measurement and ecological momentary assessment (EMA) will be utilized to measure potential treatment mechanisms including motivation, self-efficacy, and treatment adherence. Other variables including stress/adversity, psychosocial resources, negative affect, nicotine dependence, and treatment adherence will also be assessed.

Individuals (N = 320) will be recruited during their initial visit to the Tobacco Cessation Clinic. Eligible participants (N = 320) will be randomized to: 1) Standard Care, which is counseling and pharmacological treatment (SC; n = 160), or 2) SC + adjunctive financial incentives through 12 weeks post-quit (CM; n = 160). All participants will be followed weekly from 1 week pre-quit through 4 weeks post-quit, and will return for visits at 8, 12, and 26 weeks post-quit. Biochemically verified 7-day point prevalence abstinence will be assessed at all visits, though abstinence at 26 weeks post-quit (longer-term abstinence) will serve as the primary outcome variable. Those randomized to the CM intervention will have the opportunity to earn small gift cards for biochemically-verified abstinence through 12 weeks post-quit. The value of the gift cards will escalate weekly with continuous abstinence from the quit date through 4 weeks post-quit. Additional gift cards for abstinence may be earned at 8 and 12 weeks post-quit. We also hope to gain a better understanding of CM treatment mechanisms and to identify other factors that directly influence cessation via traditional questionnaire and smartphone-based ecological momentary assessment approaches. Smartphone technology allows for "real-time" data collection to more accurately capture important cessation-related variables, and will be used to deliver gain-framed messages to support and strengthen the CM intervention. Participants will complete traditional questionnaire measures on a laptop computer weekly from 1 week pre-quit through 4 weeks post-quit, and at 8, 12, and 26 weeks post-quit. Assessments will be completed by participants either before or after their counseling appointments, for which they will receive reimbursement in the form of gift cards. Participants will also receive a smartphone at the 1 week pre-quit visit and they will be asked to carry it with them at all times through 4 weeks post-quit in order to complete EMAs (5 weeks total). Participants will be prompted to complete EMA assessments 5 times per day (4 random assessments + 1 daily diary) for five consecutive weeks. Participants will be compensated upon the return of the smartphone, based on the percentage of random/daily diary assessments that they completed. Description of Standard Care. According to the Clinical Practice Guideline, currently recommended components of an intensive tobacco treatment intervention include 1) initial assessment of willingness to participate, 2) the use of multiple types of clinicians (e.g., medical, non-medical), 3) at least 4 treatment sessions, in an individual- or group-counseling format, that are greater than 10 minutes in duration, 4) counseling that includes problem-solving, skills training, and social support components, and 5) and the opportunity to use effective medications to aid in tobacco cessation (e.g., nicotine patch, varenicline). The clinic currently offers all components of standard care. Specifically, individuals who would like to quit smoking are referred (typically via electronic medical record). Patients are scheduled for their initial appointment with a Tobacco Treatment Specialist for an individual counseling session and to discuss pharmacological treatment options. Nicotine replacement therapy is provided during the session, or other medications are prescribed via communication with the patient's physician or by a provider on-site. Those enrolled in the current study will be encouraged to attend at least 5 weekly group sessions to facilitate follow-up and the delivery of study incentives. Visit 1, Part 1 (Recruitment/Screening). Individuals attending the initial clinic intake session will be provided with a 1-page informational handout with information about the study. After the session, study staff will check in with potential participants regarding their interest. Study staff will review the consent form with interested participants, and they will be screened for eligibility on-site in a private room in the clinic. Participant eligibility for the current study will not influence eligibility for standard treatment through the clinic. The Rapid Estimate of Adult Literacy in Medicine (REALM; see Appendix A) will be administered to ensure that all participants are able to read at ≥ sixth grade level (i.e., required to complete EMA and self-report questionnaires). Expired carbon monoxide (CO) will be measured with a Vitalograph BreathCO carbon monoxide monitor. Participants will be questioned about their 1) insurance status 2) age, 3) current level of smoking, 4) willingness to quit smoking, and 5) willingness/ability to attend 6 weekly sessions (including the first visit). Eligible participants may complete the assessment portion of visit 1. Visit 1, Part 2 (Pre-Quit Assessment). Participants will complete self-report questionnaires on a laptop computer; and expired CO, weight, and height will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. Participants will be provided with an Android smartphone and instructed regarding the use of the phone (participants may make personal calls) as well as the EMA procedures. Participants will receive 4 random prompts and 1 daily diary prompt (in the morning) during the normal waking hours each day for four consecutive weeks. Participants will be instructed to quit smoking at bedtime or 10:00 pm (whichever occurs first), on the evening prior to their next scheduled counseling session (one week later). Participants will be randomized to Standard Care (SC) or CM using a random numbers table and advised of their group assignment at the conclusion of visit 1. The appropriate schedule of payments (SC or CM) will be discussed with all participants (see Table 1). Visit 1 takes approximately 1 hour to complete, and participants will be scheduled to return for visit 2. Visit 2 (Quit Day). Participants will complete self-report questionnaires on a laptop computer; and expired CO and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. Visit 2 takes approximately 40 minutes to complete. Participants randomized to the CM treatment will receive an additional payment if they self-report abstinence from smoking since 10 p.m. the prior evening, and their expired is CO level is \< 10 ppm (please note that the less stringent cut-off of 10 ppm will be used to verify abstinence at the first visit only, due to the recency of quitting). Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status only. Visit 3 (1 Week Post-Quit). Participants will complete self-report questionnaires on a laptop computer; and expired carbon monoxide (CO) and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. Visit 3 takes approximately 30 minutes to complete. Participants randomized to the CM treatment will receive an additional payment if they self-report continuous abstinence from smoking since the quit day and have an expired CO level of ≤ 6 ppm. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status. Visit 4 (2 Weeks Post-Quit). Expired carbon monoxide (CO) and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. The visit 4 assessment takes approximately 5 minutes to complete. Participants randomized to the CM treatment will receive payment if they self-report continuous abstinence from smoking since the quit date and have an expired CO level of ≤ 6 ppm. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status. Visit 5 (3 Weeks Post-Quit). Expired carbon monoxide (CO) and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. The visit 5 assessment will take approximately 5 minutes to complete. Participants randomized to the CM treatment will receive payment if they self-report continuous abstinence from smoking since the quit date and have an expired CO level of ≤ 6 ppm. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status. Visit 6 (4 Weeks Post-Quit). Participants will complete self-report questionnaires on a laptop computer; and expired CO and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. The visit 6 assessment will take approximately 50 minutes to complete. Upon return of the smartphones, participants will be compensated based on the percentage of completed random assessments. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone and/or mail to request that the phone be returned by mail (postage paid envelopes will be sent) or in-person at the next visit. When participants return the phone they will be compensated according to the compensation schedule described above. Participants randomized to the CM treatment will receive an additional payment if they self-report continuous abstinence from smoking since the quit date and have an expired CO level of ≤ 6 ppm. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status. Visit 7 (8 Weeks Post-Quit). Participants will complete self-report questionnaires on a laptop computer; and expired CO and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. Participants will receive a payment for completion of the in-person assessments, which will take approximately 30 minutes to complete. Participants randomized to the CM treatment will receive an additional payment if they self-report abstinence from smoking over the past 7 days and have an expired CO level of ≤ 6 ppm. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status. Visit 8 (12 Weeks Post-Quit). Participants will complete self-report questionnaires on a laptop computer; and expired CO and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. Participants will receive a payment for completion of the in-person assessments, which will take approximately 30 minutes to complete. Participants randomized to the CM treatment will receive an additional payment if they self-report abstinence from smoking over the past 7 days and have an expired CO level of ≤ 6 ppm. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status. Visit 9 (26 Weeks Post-Quit Follow-Up). Participants will complete self-report questionnaires on a laptop computer; and expired CO and weight will be measured in a private room to ensure confidentiality. Participants will receive a payment for completion of the in-person assessments, which will take approximately 40 minutes to complete. Saliva cotinine will also be measured via NicAlert test strips to provide additional evidence of abstinence. Participants who do not attend will be contacted by phone to obtain their self-reported smoking status.