Manometry vs Clinical Assessment in the Detection of Trapped Lung in Patients With Suspected Pleural Malignancy

Overview

Malignant pleural effusion is a common clinical problem with median survival of approximately 6 months thus efficient management of Malignant pleural effusion is important. In patients with a Trapped Lung, pleurodesis will be unsuccessful and an indwelling pleural catheter should be inserted instead. Accurate detection of Trapped Lung prior to insertion would avoid futile attempts at talc pleurodesis, re-intervention following failed pleurodesis and allow adequate time to plan for an indwelling pleural catheter insertion.Pleural manometry allows direct and objective measurement of intra-pleural pressure during pleural fluid aspiration.The primary aim of this study is to determine whether the addition of digital pleural manometry to clinical judgment, prior to and during local anaesthetic thoracoscopy, results in a clinically meaningful improvement in Trapped Lung detection.

Malignant pleural effusion is a common clinical problem with median survival of approximately 6 months. Efficient management of Malignant pleural effusion is therefore a major priority for patients, for whom failed procedures and the need for repeat hospital admissions limits their time at home with family and friends. The management of Malignant pleural effusion involves either complete pleural fluid drainage followed by some form of pleurodesis or insertion of an indwelling pleural catheter. Apposition of the parietal and visceral pleural surfaces is a pre-requisite for successful pleurodesis. In patients with a non-expansile, or Trapped Lung, pleurodesis will be unsuccessful and an indwelling pleural catheter should be inserted instead. Accurate detection of Trapped Lung prior to insertion would avoid futile attempts at talc pleurodesis, re-intervention following failed pleurodesis and allow adequate time to plan for an indwelling pleural catheter insertion, including training of the patient's District Nurses. Clinical judgment is currently used to detect Trapped Lung. This involves review of available imaging and direct visualisation of the surface of the lung during local anaesthetic thoracoscopy. Unfortunately, recent data suggest this is frequently inaccurate, with 30% and 13% of cases of Trapped Lung correctly identified in recent local and national audit data respectively. Pleural manometry allows direct and objective measurement of intra-pleural pressure during pleural fluid aspiration. Pleural pressure measurements can also be used to compute Pleural Elastance, defined as change in pleural pressure divided by change in pleural volume. Previous studies have shown that a rapid and sustained drop in intra-pleural pressure during fluid aspiration can predict Trapped Lung but these data have not been prospectively compared with current clinical practice. The primary aim of this study is to determine whether the addition of digital pleural manometry to clinical judgment, prior to and during local anaesthetic thoracoscopy, results in a clinically meaningful improvement in Trapped Lung detection. Digital pleural manometry will be recorded using a Conformité Européene marked (CE-marked) device used within its existing clinical indication (developed in conjunction with our commercial partner Rocket Medical plc). 65 Subjects will have a single study visit, which will coincide with their planned clinical admission for local anaesthetic thoracoscopy. Subjects will exit the study after a follow-up clinic visit 3 months after the date of local anaesthetic thoracoscopy. A study-specific volumetric Magnetic Resonance Imaging scan of the pleural cavity will be performed as per pre-defined imaging protocols. The study will be performed at a single centre: Queen Elizabeth University Hospital, Glasgow.