Appropriate management of analgesia for proximal femoral fractures is a common problem in the emergency department (ED). Side effects from morphine usage such as nausea, vomiting, respiratory depression, sedation, and obstipation are especially pronounced in elderly. Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block (FICB) holds promise as a simple and safe, and effective alternative method to reduce pain. Local anaesthetic injected in the anatomic space underlying the fascia iliaca, spreads to block the nerves traversing it. This regional anaesthesia includes the femoral nerve. Previous studies in the ED showed promise but lacked blinding, involved low numbers of subjects, or did not use ultrasound localisation of the injection site. The latter is becoming common practice. In this randomised placebo controlled trial the FICB with ultrasound localisation of injection of levobupivacaïne will be compared to the FICB with placebo. It aims to prove that less morphine is used in the intervention group. Other research parameters are pain scores and minor adverse events related to morphine use.
Proximal femoral fractures are common in the ED. A major challenge in such subjects is pain management. Suboptimal pain control is associated with stress, a prolonged hospital stay and delirium. Pain or fear of pain can limit early mobilisation, an important goal in treatment. Therefore early pain management is essential. Standard analgesic care consists of acetaminophen, opiates and/or Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAID's). Opiates can cause respiratory depression, constipation, drowsiness, nausea and vomiting. Especially elderly patients are at risk for these side effects Regional nerve blocks are increasingly being adopted as an alternative pain management to systemic analgesia in the ED. One of such is the Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block (FICB). This is safe and simple to perform. Results from studies, despite lacking ultrasound guidance are promising. No permanent disability resulted from the few minor complications that have been reported. These include bladder perforation, pneumoretroperitoneum and neuropathy of the femoral nerve. Furthermore no additional treatment was necessary. Ultrasound prevents occurrence of such complications. The studies that have compared this specific block to standard analgesia have shown that regional anaesthesia may be superior. However these studies have low inclusion numbers and lack of randomisation and/or blinding.. Literature up until now has used the numerical rating scale (NRS) as a primary outcome. Although the NRS is a very trustworthy method of measuring pain, the score is a subjective outcome Morphine consumption on the other hand is more objective. The FICB involves the anatomic space situated at the level of the groin in which important nerves that supply the hip joint lie. Anteriorly the space is covered by the iliac fascia. It is therefore known as the fascia iliaca compartment. By introducing a large volume of local anaesthetic solutions, the femoral, lateral femoral cutaneous and to a lesser extent the obturator nerve are anesthetized. Solutions can spread easily within the compartment. Therefore a safe position injection site can be chosen, minimizing the risk of intravascular injection and nerve damage. The classic position for injection is about 3 centimetres lateral from the femoral nerve. In the original FICB the injection site is determined by using landmarks. The fascia iliaca compartment is then approached by introducing a blunt needle, which enables the physician to feel a 'pop' twice. The first pop is felt when the fascia lata is pierced, the second when the fascia iliaca is passed. Most ED's nowadays have access to ultrasound. When used for FICB placement, the local anaesthetic solution is visualized as it is introduced into the space. Therefore a higher chance of successful placement of agent and a lower risk of complications can be expected. So far no large double blind randomised placebo controlled trials have evaluated morphine use in ultrasound guided placement of local anaesthetic agents with FICB in the ED. This study is designed as such. Total morphine use will be taken as the primary outcome, administered in the form of patient controlled analgesia (PCA).
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
QUADRUPLE
Enrollment
55
Levobupivacaïne for injection 7.5 mg/kg diluted with Sodium Chloride 0,9%
Sodium Chloride 0,9% for injection/infusion.
Acetaminophen 500 milligram tablet
Morphine 1 mg/ml solution for infusion.
Ultrasound guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block with levobupivacaine placed in the emergency department by an emergency physician.
Ultrasound guided Fascia Iliaca Compartment Block with placebo placed in the emergency department by an emergency physician.
Zuyderland Medisch Centrum
Heerlen, Zuid Limburg, Netherlands
Mean morphine consumption in milligrams per hour with PCA pump, extracted from PCA-pump memory (mg / hour).
The primary objective is to assess if ultrasound guided FICB with levobupivacaïne results in reduced morphine consumption in ED patients with a proximal femoral fracture at six hours after FICB placement. The morphine consumption will be extracted from the memory from the PCA pump.
Time frame: From FICB placement up to 6 hours.
Morphine consumption in milligrams per hour at each hour in the time preceding operation. (mg / hour)
To assess if there is a difference in morphine consumption at different time points in the time until operation. Data will be extracted from PCA pump memory.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours. Time point: each hour
Average of PCA-pump requests for morphine per hour (presses / hour)
The amount of times per hour a patient presses the PCA-pump to receive a bolus of morphine preoperatively.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours. Time point: each hour
Average time to first morphine administration with PCA-pump (minutes)
Average time until patient requests first morphine dose by pressing PCA-pump button.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours.
Average pain score at different time points.
Pain scores will be reported with the Numerical Rating Scale (NRS). The NRS is a 11 point scale that is used in the hospital pain protocol. 0 equals to no pain at all, 10 is the worst pain one can imagine. It is regarded as a reliable instrument for pain assessment in patients. Patients will be asked to keep track of their pain score at different time points, starting after FICB placement. They will be asked to report their pain score hourly until 22.00h and from 7.00h the next day. The pain scores will be measured with a dedicated android application, with which patients are asked to self-report their hourly pain scores. When patients are asleep no NRS will be recorded, unless they are awake. Also nurses will report pain scores following their normal rounds when changing shifts. A sleeping patient will be regarded as having a low pain score.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours. Time point: each hour
Difference in pain scores at movement.
The ED or ward nurse will ask and record the NRS when mobilising patients when necessary. Such situations include for example: bedpan for micturition or stools and bed to bed transfer. The recorded data will include time point, situation and NRS. Pain scores will be reported with the Numerical Rating Scale (NRS). The NRS is a 11 point scale that is used in the hospital pain protocol. 0 equals to no pain at all, 10 is the worst pain one can imagine.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours. Time point: each hour
Patients with occurence of NRS > 3.
The number of patient with a NRS \> 3, recorded by the patient in the preoperative time.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours. Time point at 24 hours.
Number of patients with a delirium in preoperative period.
The Delirium Observation Screening (DOS) scale is a validated screening tool for detecting delirium in hospitalised patients. In this hospital the DOS scale is routinely screened three times daily by ward nurses. The DOS will also be reported for participating patients in the preoperative period. Subjects with a reported DOS of ≥ 3 are regarded as being at high risk for having a delirium.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours. Time point at 24 hours.
The number of patients with morphine related side effects.
A patient will be regarded of having a side effect of morphine in case of any of the following: * Occurrence of nausea * Occurrence of vomiting * Administration of antiemetic medication * Episode of respiratory depression (\< 10 breaths/minute) * Episode of new hypoxia (SaO2 \< 90 % ) * Administration of naloxone, which will be registered by the nurse on the CRF. * Episodes of new hypotension. In this trial hypotension is defined as a systolic blood pressure \<90 mmHg, mean arterial pressure \<60 mmHg or a drop in systolic blood pressure \>40 mmHg. * Sedation score \> 1. This wil be reported by the nurse with the Pasero Opioïd Induced Sedation Scale, as is prescribed by hospital protocol. S = normal sleep, 1 = drowsy but easy to rouse, 2 = sedated and difficult to rouse, and 3 = unconscious).
Time frame: This will be assessed by the nurse at the rounds each shift up to 3 times daily until operation or up to 24 hours.
Number of patients with treatment-related adverse events as assessed by CTCAE v4.0.
Adverse events relating to the fascia iliaca compartment block or morphine use will be reported.
Time frame: Time from FICB placement until operation, up to 24 hours.
Time spent on FICB placement in seconds.
The duration of ultrasound guided FICB placement will be measured.
Time frame: The time from needle entering patient, until procedure is terminated by the emergency physician.
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.