Most recent guidelines suggest central venous access must be performed with real-time ultrasound guidance, and the most recommended site for cannulation is internal jugular vein (IJV); however, it is recognized that evidence for other sites is, at present, limited. Besides, guidelines does not account for patients with small vein cross-sectional area and/or respirophasic collapse, which can make the procedure more difficult or even impossible. The investigators aim to compare three different insertion sites for central venous access, with real-time ultrasound guidance
Ultrasound-guided cannulation of central veins is successful in \>95% of the cases, according to the largest study so far. However, this and other studies with similar success rate, are performed in patients with general anesthesia and/or neuromuscular blockade, without spontaneous respiratory efforts. Critical care physicians and many other specialists frequently need to cannulate patients in special circumstances as hypovolemia, pain, anxiety, and respiratory efforts that promotes respirophasic variation in cross-sectional area, and even complete collapse of the vessel. These changes can increase the probability of posterior wall or arterial puncture, hematomas, pneumothorax, etc. Supraclavicular approach for cannulation of the subclavian vein is a method described since 1965, also giving direct access to the innominate vein, a larger vessel which is rarely collapsible regardless of volume status or respiratory efforts. Based on a previous pilot trial, in this multi-center, prospective, randomized, controlled trial, the investigators aim to compare the successfulness and safety of ultrasound-guided central venous cannulation at 3 different sites: internal jugular, subclavian, and innominate veins.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
DOUBLE
Enrollment
308
Catheterization of internal jugular vein with real-time (in-plane) method, with neutral neck position. Standard aseptic technique.
Catheterization of subclavian/axillary vein with infra-clavicular approach with real-time (in-plane) method, without shoulder retraction. Standard aseptic technique.
Catheterization of innominate vein with supra-clavicular approach with real-time (in-plane) method, with neutral shoulder position and no shoulder retraction. Standard aseptic technique.
Hospital Civil Fray Antonio Alcalde
Guadalajara, Mexico
Cannulation failure rate
Failure to cannulate selected vein at first attempt
Time frame: Baseline
Central line-associated blood infection rate
Confirmed with blood cultures
Time frame: 28 days
Collapsibility associated with failure
Percentage of vein collapsibility independently associated with cannulation failure
Time frame: Baseline
Cannulation number of attempts
Number of attempts needed to attain cannulation
Time frame: Baseline
Procedure time
Time from skin puncture to guidewire confirmed into vessel (minutes)
Time frame: Baseline
Arterial puncture rate
Confirmed immediately after procedure with vascular ultrasound
Time frame: Baseline
Hematoma formation rate
Confirmed immediately after procedure with vascular ultrasound
Time frame: 7 days
Neumothorax rate
Confirmed immediately after procedure with lung ultrasound
Time frame: 7 days
Hemothorax rate
Confirmed immediately after procedure with lung ultrasound
Time frame: 7 days
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.