This study is intended to demonstrate the 5-year long-term safety and efficacy of the Simplify® Cervical Artificial Disc ("Simplify Disc") in subjects enrolled in the non-randomized two-level Simplify Disc Investigational Device Exemption (IDE) study. This study was conducted under IDE G150206
Study Type
OBSERVATIONAL
Enrollment
291
The Simplify Disc is a cervical artificial disc manufactured from polyether ether ketone (PEEK) endplates and a mobile, zirconia-toughened alumina ceramic core.
Orthopaedic Education and Research Institute of Southern California
Orange, California, United States
The Spine Institute for Spine Restoration
Santa Monica, California, United States
Clinical Composite Success
Individual success for Simplify Disc was defined as follows: * Neck Disability Index (NDI) score improvement of at least 15 points from pre-operative; * Maintenance or improvement in neurological status; * No serious adverse event classified as implant associated or implant/surgical procedure associated; and * No additional surgical procedure classified as a "failure."
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549; start date 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-op. Comparison data from historical controls up to 60 months post-op is also reported
Clinically Significant Improvement in One or More Radicular Symptoms or Myelopathy
An arm pain questionnaire was used to measure radicular symptoms and compare to baseline symptoms in the IDE study. Changes of at least 2 points on a 10-point scale were regarded as clinically significant (0=no pain; 10=worst pain)
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549; start date 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-op. Comparison data from historical controls up to 60 months post-op is also reported
Health Survey; 36-Item Short Form Survey (SF-36) - Physical Component Score (PCS) Maintenance or Improvement
The PCS is a sub-score of the SF-36. The SF-36 is a multipurpose survey with 36 questions. The questions were combined, scored, and weighted to create two scores that provide glimpses into mental and physical functioning and overall health-related quality-of-life. Higher scores indicate better outcomes. Scores range from 0-50. Maintenance or improvement was defined as PCS(Postop) - PCS(Preop) ≥0.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549; start date 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-op. Comparison data from historical controls up to 60 months post-op is also reported
Health Survey; 36-Item Short Form Survey (SF-36) - Mental Component Score (MCS) Maintenance or Improvement
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.
Spine Education and Research Foundation
Thornton, Colorado, United States
Connecticut Orthopaedic Specialists
Hamden, Connecticut, United States
Kennedy-White Orthopedic Center
Sarasota, Florida, United States
NorthShore University Health System
Evanston, Illinois, United States
Indiana Spine Group
Carmel, Indiana, United States
Parkview Research Center
Fort Wayne, Indiana, United States
Orthopaedic Institute of Western Kentucky
Paducah, Kentucky, United States
Spine Institute of Louisiana
Shreveport, Louisiana, United States
...and 8 more locations
The MCS is a sub-score of the SF-36. The SF-36 is a multipurpose survey with 36 questions. The questions were combined, scored, and weighted to create two scores that provide glimpses into mental and physical functioning and overall health-related quality-of-life. Higher scores indicate better outcomes. Scores range from 0-50. Maintenance or improvement was defined as PCS(Postop) - PCS(Preop) ≥0.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549; start date 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-op. Comparison data from historical controls up to 60 months post-op is also reported
Dysphagia Handicap Index (DHI Scale)
Dysphagia Handicap Index score for the Simplify Disc subjects at 60 months. A higher score is indicative of a less desirable outcome. It is scored 0-100. Data was not collected on DHI in the historical ACDF control group. Only Simplify Disc subjects are reported. This was pre-specified in the study design.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549 with start date of 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-operative.
Patient Satisfaction
Patient satisfaction was assessed by survey based on the response to the statement "I am satisfied with the results of my surgery" at 60 months. Answer options ranged from definitely true to definitely false.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549; start date 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-op. Comparison data from historical controls up to 60 months post-op is also reported
Physician's Perception
Results at 60 months were categorized by the physician's perception of the subject's condition (excellent, good, fair, or poor).
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549; start date 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-op. Comparison data from historical controls up to 60 months post-op is also reported
Change in Average Disc Height (Superior Index Level)
Average disc height (superior index level) at 60 months was compared to the baseline measurement in the IDE study and the change was calculated. Measurements were scored by an independent core lab. Average disc height was calculated as the simple average of the anterior and posterior disc heights. Data was not collected on average disc height in the historical ACDF control group. Only Simplify Disc subjects are reported. This was pre-specified in the study design.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549 with start date of 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-operative.
Change in Average Disc Height (Inferior Index Level)
Average disc height (inferior index level) at 60 months was compared to the baseline measurement in the IDE study and the change was calculated. Measurements were scored by an independent core lab. Average disc height was calculated as the simple average of the anterior and posterior disc heights. Data was not collected on average disc height in the historical ACDF control group. Only Simplify Disc subjects are reported. This was pre-specified in the study design.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549 with start date of 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-operative.
Adjacent Level Deterioration - Superior Adjacent Level
Outcome reports the number and percentage of subjects with adjacent level disc degeneration (ALDD) above the index level based on X-ray images. Degeneration was graded as none (no degenerative changes), doubtful (Minimal osteophytosis only), minimal (Definite osteophytosis with some sclerosis of anterior part of vertebral plates), moderate (Marked osteophytosis and sclerosis of vertebral plates with slight narrowing of disk space), or severe (Large osteophytes, marked sclerosis of vertebral plates, and marked narrowing of disk space). Assessments were made by an independent core lab. Data was not collected on adjacent level deterioration in the historical ACDF control group. Only Simplify Disc subjects are reported. This was pre-specified in the study design.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549 with start date of 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-operative.
Adjacent Level Deterioration - Inferior Adjacent Level
Outcome reports the number and percentage of subjects with adjacent level disc degeneration (ALDD) below the index level based on X-ray images. Degeneration was graded as none (no degenerative changes), doubtful (Minimal osteophytosis only), minimal (Definite osteophytosis with some sclerosis of anterior part of vertebral plates), moderate (Marked osteophytosis and sclerosis of vertebral plates with slight narrowing of disk space), or severe (Large osteophytes, marked sclerosis of vertebral plates, and marked narrowing of disk space). Assessments were made by an independent core lab. Data was not collected on adjacent level deterioration in the historical ACDF control group. Only Simplify Disc subjects are reported. This was pre-specified in the study design.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549 with start date of 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-operative.
Displacement or Migration of the Device
Displacement or migration of the device at 60 months was be compared to immediate post-op data collected in the IDE study. This was be graded by the radiographic core lab. Migration was considered "present" if changes of \>3mm were noted. The superior index level and inferior index level was assessed separately.
Time frame: Data through 24 months gathered in IDE (NCT03123549; start date 4/1/17). This PAS (start date 8/1/21) followed the same patient cohort through 60 months post-op. Comparison data from historical controls up to 60 months post-op is also reported