Mind-Body Modalities for Nursing Students

Overview

Background: Nursing students around the world can experience tremendous stress due to their multi-faceted responsibilities. Stress is related to negative health and academic outcomes. Mind-body connection modalities have been used successfully to reduce stress and improve health among healthy and ill individuals in various cultures, but their effects have not yet been studied in the Arab culture. Thus, the purpose of this study was to examine and compare the effects of three of such modalities including progressive muscle relaxation (PMR), guided imagery (GI), and mindfulness meditation (MM) on stress and health outcomes in Jordanian nursing students. Methods: Using a randomized controlled design, 124 nursing students will be randomly assigned to 4 groups at a large university in Jordan. The 3 experimental groups (PMR, GI, and MM) will participate in 5 30-minute sessions (one session/week for 5 weeks) led by experienced trainers, in a private room during their clinical days. The control group will stay calm for 30 minutes during introducing the study interventions in another room at the university. The health outcomes will be measured at baseline (Time 1) and the end (Time 3) of the intervention in each group using different physical and self-report measures classified into different health categories such as cognitive health outcomes (executive brain function, stressful appraisal, mindfulness), physical health outcomes (e.g. physical symptoms, heart rate, blood pressure, neurobiological markers such as dopamine, serotonin, cortisol, adrenaline, and noradrenaline), and psychological health outcomes (e.g. depression, anxiety).

Design This study uses a blocked randomized controlled design. The study subjects will be selected using a convenience sampling method. When selected, the subjects will be randomly assigned to either one of the 4 study groups using a stratified random strategy (stratifying variable= academic year of study). The study groups (PMR, MM, GI, Control group) will received 5 30-minute weekly sessions of their assigned intervention over 5 weeks. However, there will be a 4-hours workshop explaining the purposes and techniques of the study interventions before introducing the actual session. The subjects will be asked and encouraged to practice their assigned intervention for 30 minutes daily at home. The dependent variables will be measured three times for the 4 groups: at baseline, at the middle (after the second session), and at the end of intervention. Participants Participants are undergraduate nursing students who will be selected using a random sampling method from Jordan University of Science and Technology. Determination of Sample Size Using G\* Power software 3.1, mixed-design (within groups-between groups) repeated measures ANOVA, an alpha of .05, a power of 0.8, the number of measurements of 3, the number of groups of 4, and a moderate effect size of 0.25, the sample size of 180 was generated. A 15 % attrition rate was reported in a previous study with variables similar to the present study. Considering an expected attrition rate of 15 %, the required final total sample size 210. Intervention In the current study, the Attentional Behavioral Cognitive (ABC) Relaxation theory's standardized versions of PMR, MM, and GI will be used, including 5 30-minute weekly sessions of each version. Each group will be encouraged to practice once at home daily. An additional educational 4-hour workshop about each intervention will be provided before the actual training session to enhance the subjects' understanding of their assigned intervention. Especially such interventions are rarely practiced and little known about them in Jordan. In the initial educational session, the PI will separately provide a power point presentation to participants in each experimental group about the rationale and procedures of their assigned intervention and a demonstration of the entire intervention protocol. Participants will be asked briefly to practice their assigned intervention and then evaluated by the PI to make sure the interventions have been done correctly. The PI will give the participants the opportunity to ask questions during the educational session During the actual training sessions, the interventions will be introduced to subjects in the experimental groups using an audio drive designed and produced by the PI based on the ABC Relaxation Theory's guidelines and protocols. All groups will be given identical instructions; only the specific instructions regarding the intervention will be different. The participants in all groups will be asked to close their eyes. All of the groups will be meet in an academic classroom, where the interventions will be provided. Participants will sit in hard chairs behind a desk. Floors will be hard tile. Lights will be dimmed during relaxation phases, and turned on when measures will be filled out. The study groups will be given a audio drive about their assigned intervention and encouraged to practice their assigned intervention daily over the study. They will be asked to document their practices of the assigned intervention at home. The PI will randomly select sessions to evaluate the delivery of intervention using checklists produced according to the developed protocols. PI is an experienced practitioner who received a stress management training at the Psychology Department, Kent State University 7 years ago. Since then, PI has been practicing the stress management techniques daily, especially used in the current study. Progressive Muscle Relaxation PMR (ABC Relaxation Theory Version) involves a tense-let go exercise of 11 muscle groups including hand, arm, arm and sides, back, shoulder, face, front of neck, stomach, chest, leg, and foot. This tense-let go exercise is performed twice for each muscle group. The tensing up phase for each muscle group should last for 5 to 10 seconds and the letting go phase for 20-30 seconds. Simultaneously, the subjects will be asked to pay attention to the sensations of muscle tension and relaxation. After the tense-let go exercise, subjects are asked to systematically scan the muscle groups to notice and let go any remaining muscle tension. The entire exercise should take around 30 minutes, not counting instructions and times of measurement. Guided Imagery Guided imagery (ABC Relaxation Theory Version) involves creating in one's mind or imagining a passive relaxing places or activities. In sense imagery, one simply imagines sensations associated with a relaxing setting or activity. The relaxation approach involves the sense of sight, sound, touch, and smell. The categories of stimuli consist of: (1) Travel such as boats, plains, trains, balloons, horses, (2) outdoor nature settings such as mountains, gardens, and forest, (3) water such as rivers, lakes, ocean, beach, rain, and (4) indoor settings such as childhood home, castle, religious institution, and cabin. Mindfulness Meditation The ABC Relaxation Theory Version of the mindfulness meditation will be used in the current study. The mindful mediators are neutral observers who view the world as it is, without reactions, judgments, and evaluations. They quietly attend to, note, and let go of every internal external stimulus such as thought, feeing, sensation, sound, idea that enters awareness. They do not try to think about, push away, and do anything with these stimuli experienced and do not have to figure out the connections between each stimulus. They simply let each stimulus come and go and wait for the next stimulus. They do not have to be concerned about distractions. Each time they are distracted, they note it as yet another passing stimulus (Ah, a distraction… how interesting"). Control Group Participants in the control condition will be instructed to sit with their eyes closed and relax during the intervention periods. Participants in the control group will follow an identical procedure and time periods as the experimental groups. For instance, when the experimental groups will practice for 30 minutes, the participants in the control group will be asked to sit with eyes closed and relax for 30 minutes. Procedure First, approvals from the JUST institutional review boards will be obtained. After that, a translation from English to Arabic and pilot testing of the English versions of the scales used in the current study will be performed. The scales used in the study will be introduced for 30 Jordanian undergraduate nursing students, and then the construct validity, reliability (internal consistency), readability of these scales will be examined. After taking the permission of the dean of nursing college and class's instructors, the PI will visit students in their classrooms. As the lecture finishes, The PI will make an announcement about the title and objectives of the study and ask the students who would like to participate to contact him using a business card including the PI's contact information (his name, phone number, and email) given for each one. The contact information will be used only for the purpose of the study. The PI will arrange an initial meeting to meet with students who would like to participate on another day in a private room at the university. At this meeting, the PI will inform the students the study's objectives, risks, benefits, and confidentiality and answer questions that they have about the study. Also, they will be assured that they have the full right to refuse or discontinue the participation at any time and that such refusal or discontinuation will not affect their academic achievements in any way. If agree to participate and eligibility criteria are met, informed consent will be obtained at the meeting. After that, the participants will be randomly assigned equally to the study groups using a stratified random assignment method (stratifying variable= academic year of study). Finally, dates and times for sessions will be set up and sent to the participants using their e-mails. In the 4-hour education session, the baseline measurements of the study variables will first be obtained. Then the PI will separately provide a power point presentation to participants in each experimental group as explained previously. At the end of the workshop, to avoid experiment contamination, the participants in each experimental group will be asked not to share any information related to the intervention with subjects in other groups. The actual training will be introduced to subjects in the experimental groups, using an audio CD designed and produced by the PI based on the interventions' guidelines and protocols. Based on the ABC Relaxation Theory (Smith, 2005), at least two, and preferably five sessions of actual mind-body training should be provided to evoke relaxation and optimize health. In the proposed study, the dependent variables will be measured at the middle and at the end of intervention to see whether further health benefits occur between these two measurements. The sessions will be provided to the study groups in a private, quiet, comfortable, and spacious room at the university. The dependent variables will be measured three times for the groups: at baseline, after 2nd actual training session, and at the end of intervention (after 5th session), as mentioned previously. Various strategies will be followed to decrease measurement errors potentially affected by variations of data collection procedure. For example, filling out the questionnaire may be stressful for some subjects and, in turn, influences objective measures. Therefore, the self-reports measures will be completed after taking the objective measures. Also, all study measurements in the intervention and control groups will be undertaken in the same conditions (i.e. same room temperature and environment) by well-trained nurses as much as possible. The ELISA protocol, including blood sampling will strictly be followed. The neurotransmitters/hormones will measured between 8:30 and 9:30 am for all subjects at sitting position. Drinking coffee, tea, and having should be avoided 6 hours before the measurement of neurotransmitters/hormones. To decrease venipuncture-related pain during blood sampling, EMLA cream will be used, which has been found effective in decreasing venipuncture-related pain in different populations. In addition, quiet environments, free from distraction, will be maintained with a "Do Not Disturb" sign on the door of the rooms during the intervention and data collection. Statistical Analysis Statistical analysis will be conducted using SPSS software (version 23). Descriptive statistics will be used to describe the sample. The sample and variables will be described by measures of central tendency and dispersion appropriate to the level of measurement. Initial analyses will be conducted to ensure that the randomization across covariates was successful. The gender, marital status, employment, nationality, and smoking behavior variables will be all tested at baseline using Chi-square to demonstrate that they are not significantly different between groups. Independent t-tests will be run at baseline measurements of dependent variables to make sure the study groups will be not significantly different on these variables before introducing the study intervention. One-way- ANOVA will be used to test the study hypotheses. Post hoc t-tests will be run to examine if the study groups will be significantly different on the dependent variables at end of the intervention. In case of having confounding effects of some variables, ANCOVA will be used. Ethical consideration Physical or psychological harm or risks that might be associated with the measurement activities or intervention employed in the current study will be minimal. One risk that might have resulted from the study was making venipuncture-related pain. Thus, ELMA cream has been used before blood sampling to decrease venipuncture-related pain. Moreover, trained nurses will draw blood from participants, following the Blood Sampling Guideline of the European Federation of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine, 2017. Potential benefits of the measurement activities and intervention to study subjects included increased knowledge and awareness about their health and mind-body modalities. For society, potential benefits included a greater understanding of the effects of mind-body modalities on stress reduction and the potential improvement of the study population's health. In this study, potential benefits are believed to exceed risks. To protect the ethical principle of respect for subjects, all subjects will be informed about the purpose and nature of the study, and informed consent will be obtained from all. Students will be assured that they have the full right to refuse to participate in the study, and that such refusal will not affect their academic achievements in any way. They will also be assured that their information would not be made available to others without prior consent, the study data will be locked in a secured storage area in a locked locker and that their names will be replaced by numbers to avoid their identification. Also, the meetings with students will be conducted in a private room at JUST and at convenient times for subjects. Moreover, to meet the ethical principle of justice, no student will be excluded from the study because of gender, ethnicity, or nationality.