This study aims to evaluate the feasibility of novel cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT)-based intervention designed to improve functional memory symptoms after concussion. Participants will be randomized to CBT or an attention-matched control intervention (cognitive rehabilitation). The primary outcomes for this trial are feasibility metrics, including recruitment, patient-perceived credibility of treatment, patient adherence to treatment, therapists' compliance with the treatment protocol, and retention.
Background: Although objectively measurable memory impairments typically resolve within weeks after sustaining a concussion, many people continue to perceive memory problems one year later. There are no known effective treatments for this condition. A promising new approach may be to target psychological mechanisms that perpetuate excessively negative perceptions of memory ability. Methods: A pilot randomized controlled trial to evaluate the feasibility of a new cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT)-based treatment program specifically designed to improve persistent memory complaints after concussion. The main inclusion criteria will be (i) concussion in the past 6 to 24 months, (ii) research diagnosis of Functional Cognitive Disorder. Participants will be randomized (1:1) into one of two groups: CBT or cognitive rehabilitation. Individuals in both groups will participate in 11 x 50-minute sessions delivered over Zoom videoconference, co-facilitated by clinical psychology graduate students under the supervision of a registered clinical psychologist. Aims: To evaluate the feasibility and potential efficacy of CBT for functional memory symptoms after concussion. Approach: Prespecified feasibility criteria on recruitment, patient-perceived credibility of treatment, patient adherence to treatment, therapists' compliance with the treatment protocol, and retention will determine the success of the pilot trial. The investigators further hypothesize that CBT will be associated with greater reductions in memory concern compared to the control intervention. Implications: The results of this pilot study will inform a larger, more definitive clinical trial focused on testing efficacy.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Cognitive behavioural therapy for functional memory symptoms after concussion is delivered by a psychologist over 11 individual (1:1) secure videoconference sessions. The core active ingredients are 1) Behavioural experiments, which acts by phasing out compensatory strategies in order to increase normal memory use and 2) Cognitive reappraisal, which aids in re-interpreting memory lapses in order to reduce reactivity to them.
Training and practice with external memory aids/compensatory strategies, adapted from Shum et al. (2011). J Rehabil Med, 43(3):216-223.
Urgent and Primary Care Center: North Vancouver
North Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Lion's Gate Hosital
North Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Richmond Hospital
Richmond, British Columbia, Canada
Recruitment
\>50% of eligible participants agree to enroll
Time frame: Week 0
Treatment credibility
\>50% of enrolled participants rate the intervention as above midpoint on credibility
Time frame: Week 2
Patient adherence
\>70% of participants attend at least 8 sessions
Time frame: Week 12
Therapists compliance
Therapists cover 95% of essential element content
Time frame: Week 12
Retention
\>80% of randomized participants complete the primary outcome measure immediately post-intervention
Time frame: Week 12
Memory concern
Satisfaction subscale of the Multifactorial Memory Questionnaire \[range=0-72; higher scores indicate greater satisfaction with memory\]
Time frame: Week 12
Avoidance
Fear-Avoidance of Memory Loss Scale \[range=5-25; higher scores indicate greater fear and avoidance\]
Time frame: Week 12
Reliance on others
Relative subscale of the Memory Compensation Questionnaire \[range=0-115; higher scores indicate greater dependence on others to remember things\]
Time frame: Week 12
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.
Masking
DOUBLE
Enrollment
30
Back in Motion (Post-Concussion Management Program)
Surrey, British Columbia, Canada
Mount Saint Joseph's Hospital
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Vancouver General Hospital
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Lifemark (Post-Concussion Management Program)
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
University of British Columbia Hospital
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Urgent and Primary Care Center: City Center
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
St. Paul's Hospital
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Catastrophizing
Adapted Pain Catastrophizing Scale \[range=0-52, higher scores indicate greater catastrophizing\]
Time frame: Week 12
Patient Global Impression of Change
Single item rated on a scale of 1 (much worse) to 5 (much better) since the start of treatment
Time frame: Week 12