Comparison of the Postoperative Use of Dextenza vs a Standard Regimen After PRK

Overview

Naval Refractive Surgery Center proposes a prospective, single-site, randomized, non-FDA regulated clinical trial with bilateral commercial treatment for for PRK. Subjects will be randomized to receive one of two postoperative steroid regimens: Dextenza (a dexamethasone ophthalmic insert) or standard of care topical Fluorometholone. Subjects will be followed for 3 months after surgery. Investigators will use objective and subjective measures to assess potential differences in postoperative healing and pain. This study will not be FDA-regulated. All study surgeries will be standard of care, with the exception of the addition of the Dextenza insert after the PRK procedure among subjects randomized to the Dextenza group.

The Dextenza in the DoD study is a prospective, randomized, comparative, single-site, non-FDA regulated clinical trial to compare two different postoperative steroid regimens in active duty populations that are treated with PRK at the Navy Refractive Surgery Center in San Diego,California. Study subjects will be randomly assigned to receive one of two post-PRK steroid regimens: 1. Dextenza (a dexamethasone ophthalmic insert manufactured by Ocular Therapeutix) 2. Standard of care topical Fluorometholone For each study subject, both eyes will be randomized to the same postoperative steroid regimen. That is, this is a bilateral eye study (not contralateral). The myopic treatments will range from 0.00 D to -8.00 D MRSE, with cylinder from -0.00 to - 3.00 D (myopia with or without astigmatism). This treatment range is within FDA-approved limits for PRK, as well as all proposed study lasers. The primary objective of this clinical trial is to evaluate the potential postoperative differences in pain and epithelial closure in active duty subjects treated with PRK at the Navy Refractive Surgery Center. Study subjects will be randomly assigned to receive one of two post-PRK steroid regimens: 1. Dextenza 1. Dextenza is a 0.4mg dexamethasone ophthalmic insert manufactured by Ocular Therapeutix. 2. It is placed into the lower lacrimal punctum immediately after PRK (bilaterally). 3. The insert slowly dissolves over time. 2. Standard of care topical Fluorometholone (0.1% ophthalmic suspension) a. Tapered over time: i. 1 drop in each eye QID for 1 st week postop. ii. 1 drop in each eye TID for 2 nd week postop. iii. 1 drop in each eye BID for 3 rd week postop. iv. 1 drop in each eye qD for 4 th week postop. This clinical trial is not regulated by the FDA. The Investiators hypothesize that there will be no statistically significant nor clinically meaningful differences in postoperative self-reported pain or epithelial closure when comparing Dextenza to Fluorometholone. The Investigators also hypothesize that adherence to the medication regimen will be higher in the Dextenza group because it is an ophthalmic insert rather than a topical medication. These potential differences will be evaluated using the following statistical methods: Chi-Square tests of dichotomous and categorical Visual Analogue Scale and COMTOL questionnaire responses (within a single time period) between Dextenza and Fluorometholone groups. McNemar's or Marginal Homoegenity tests of categorical Visual Analogue Scale and COMTOL questionnaire responses being compared over study visits between Dextenza and Fluorometholone groups. The Investigators will adjust for multiple comparisons using Bonferroni, Tukey, or Scheffe's methods for adjustment. This study will be performed in an active duty population. Subjects will undergo Wavefront Guided (VISX or similar) or Wavefront Optimized PRK (e.g., Wavelight EX500 or similar) fr the reduction or elimination of myopia with or without astigmatism. The following outcomes will include a binocular/subject-level analysis: -UCVA OU, BSCVA OU, Manifest refraction OU, Subject history, Cycloplegic refraction OU, Intraoperative events, Adverse events, Combat Driving Performance Test, Take Home questionnaire, COMTOL questionnaire, PROWL questionnaire. The following outcomes will include an analysis of each eye treated independently: UCVA OD \& OS, BSCVA OD \& OS, Manifest refraction OD \& OS, Cycloplegic refraction OD \& OS, Topography, including keratometry OD \& OS, Wavefront OD \& OS, Dilated fundus exams OD \& OS, Pachymetry OD \& OS, Slit lamp examinations OD \& OS, Intraocular pressure OD \& OS, Intraoperative events, Adverse events. The Navy is uniquely positioned to perform this comparison due to the availability of the study lasers at NMCSD and of a large subject pool and a history of good follow-up in the active duty population. RANDOMIZATION 1. Subjects will be randomized to receive either receive one of two postoperative steroid regimens: * 1\) Dextenza insert * 2\) Topical Fluorometholone regimen 2. Randomization lists will be stratified by preoperative manifest sphere to ensure balanced randomization by refractive error: * Low (-1.00 to -3.00 D SPH) * Moderate (-3.25 to -6.00 D SPH) * High (Greater than -6.00 D SPH) In cases where each eye falls into a different sphere stratum, the eye with the highest manifest sphere will be used to randomize both of the subject's eyes. STEROID REGIMEN Subjects will follow one of two randomly assigned postoperative steroid regimens: 1. Dextenza 1. Dextenza is a 0.4mg dexamethasone ophthalmic insert manufactured by Ocular Therapeutix. 2. It is placed into the lower lacrimal punctum immediately after PRK (bilaterally). 3. The insert slowly dissolves over time. 2. Standard of care topical Fluorometholone (0.1% ophthalmic suspension) a. Tapered over time: i. 1 drop in each eye QID for 1 st week postop. ii. 1 drop in each eye TID for 2 nd week postop. iii. 1 drop in each eye BID for 3 rd week postop. iv. 1 drop in each eye qD for 4 th week postop. DURATION 1.Study subjects will be followed for 3 months after PRK. 2. Including recruitment, enrollment, treatment, and 3 months of follow-up, the study is expected to last 12 months total. VISIT SCHEDULE Subjects will be seen at 5 scheduled study visits (in addition to any unanticipated interim visits): 1. Preoperative 2. Operative 3. 1 week 4. 1 month 5. 3 months NUMBER OF SUBJECTS Up to 60 subjects (120 eyes) will be enrolled to achieve the required treated eyes. Subjects will be treated with PRK bilaterally on one of the platforms (VISX, EX500, or equivalent) and will be randomized to receive one of two postoperative steroid regimens: Dextenza insert or standard of care topical Fluorometholone. DATA COLLECTION Data in this study will primarily be patient-generated. Investigators may also use patient health records, such as Genesis (e.g., for standard-of-care operative planning; verifying eligibility criteria). Investigators will prospectively collect data from eye examinations and questionnaires. The schedule for standard of care eye testing and questionnaires (PROWL, COMTOL, and the Take Home questionnaire) is listed in Table 2, Section 10.2. Take Home questionnaires with a visual analogue scale and queries about postoperative medication use will be sent home with the patients to be completed postoperatively every day until the 1 Week visit. Prior to enrollment, clinic staff will flag patients who meet preoperative exam inclusion criteria and who agree to be referred to study investigators to obtain informed consent. Eligible subjects will sign Informed Consent and HIPAA Authorization forms. These forms include language permitting study investigators to use relevant data from a standard of care preoperative examination performed by clinic staff prior to the subject signing the Informed Consent and HIPAA Authorization forms. The purpose of using the previously gathered preoperative data is To avoid a repeat preoperative visit, thus reducing patient and clinic burden and loss-to-follow- up. Preoperative and postoperative data will be added to the subject's study record and entered into an Excel Database.