The Effectiveness of Forensic Outpatient Systemic Therapy: a Multiple Case Experimental Design

Utrecht University15 enrolled

Overview

The purpose of this study is to investigate the effectiveness and mediators of Forensic Outpatient Systemic Therapy (FAST).

Forensic Outpatient Systemic Therapy (in Dutch: Forensische Ambulante Systeem Therapie; FAST) is a promising treatment for juveniles showing severe antisocial behavior, including aggression, (domestic) violence, and delinquent behavior. FAST has a flexible intensity and length, addresses individual and systemic risk and protective factors, and is responsive to the abilities of the client (system), intervention characteristics all considered crucial for effective treatment. The current study will investigate whether FAST is effective in reducing aggression of the juvenile, in reaching client formulated subgoals, and in improving family functioning (i.e., reducing juvenile-caregiver conflict and increasing caregiver responsiveness). In addition, processes of change will be examined, as well as mediation by reaching client formulated subgoals and improved family functioning. A Multiple Case Experimental Design (MCED) with an ABC design will be performed (A = baseline, B = intervention, and C = follow-up). Juveniles with primary aggression and/or anger problems (N = 15) and their caregiver(s) will be recruited.

Study Type

OBSERVATIONAL

Enrollment

Conditions

Conduct Disorder Antisocial Behavior Aggression Behavioral Disorder

Interventions

FASTBEHAVIORAL

FAST includes around 3 hours of face-to-face direct treatment time weekly and consists of a maximum of 10% online direct treatment time (i.e., treatment via phone, video-calling or texting). The treatment stage of FAST lasts five to nine months depending on the individual goals of the juvenile and the caregiver(s) and is followed by a period of aftercare.

Eligibility

Sex: ALLMin age: 12 YearsMax age: 21 Years

Medical Language ↔ Plain English

FAST therapists determine whether clients meet inclusion and exclusion criteria of FAST during the standard intake procedure of FAST. The FAST inclusion criteria are: 1. Juvenile has an estimated IQ-score of 80 or higher and/or sufficient adaptive skills to benefit from FAST; 2. Juvenile is aged 12 to 21 years old at the start of the intervention; 3. Juvenile exhibits externalizing behavior resulting in problems in at least two life areas (family, school, or leisure time), determined by clinical impressions based on information from intake and/or referrer information; 4. Juvenile has a medium to high recidivism risk, measured by the Risk Assessment Instrument for Outpatient Forensic Mental Health Care Youth (RAF GGZ Youth); 5. Presence of juvenile-caregiver relationship problems, measured by the RAF GGZ Youth; 6. Juvenile has a diagnosis of a DSM-5 behavioral disorder, which is determined using a new diagnostic process or case file analysis; 7. Juvenile and caregiver(s) cannot be motivated to follow treatment at the treatment site after multiple attempts by the therapist; 8. Juvenile resides with their caregiver(s) or is expected to return to residing with their caregiver(s) within the first two months of FAST. The FAST exclusion criteria are: 1. Juvenile exhibits severe psychiatric symptoms requiring admission; 2. Problem behavior of the juvenile is caused primarily by substance abuse problems and it is expected that treatment of the substance abuse problems will decrease the problem behavior; 3. The safety of the family members or therapist cannot be sufficiently guaranteed. To be eligible for participation in this study, one modified study inclusion criterium applies, i.e., the juvenile has primary aggression and/or anger problems (approximately 80% of referred juveniles). In addition, one study exclusion criterium applies, i.e., the juvenile is in secure residential care or confined in a correctional or detention facility at start of the intervention.

Locations (2)

de Waag

Utrecht, Netherlands

NOT_YET_RECRUITING

Utrecht University

Utrecht, Netherlands

RECRUITING

Outcomes

Primary Outcomes

Change in Aggression assessed by the Aggressive Behavior scale of the Youth Self Report (YSR)

The YSR is a self-reported instrument. The Aggressive Behavior scale contains 19 items assessing aggression. Possible scores range from 1 (never) to 100 (always).

Time frame: Twice a week during phase A, up to 5 weeks; every other week during phase B, up to 8 months; weekly during phase C, 6 weeks

Change in Aggression assessed by the Aggressive Behavior scale of the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL)

The CBCL is a caregiver-reported instrument. The Aggressive Behavior scale contains 19 items assessing aggression. Possible scores range from 1 (never) to 100 (always).

Time frame: Twice a week during phase A, up to 5 weeks; every other week during phase B, up to 8 months; weekly during phase C, 6 weeks

Change in Client Formulated Subgoals assessed by the FAST Goal list

The FAST Goal list is a self-report instrument for juveniles and caregivers. It contains 21 items with possible scores ranging from 0 (not true at all) to 100 (definitely true). The FAST Goal lists are used in an idiographic and client-guided approach. The first questionnaire in phase A contains the entire FAST Goal list and a follow-up question asks participants to prioritize their top three FAST goals. In the subsequent measurements, only the items measuring the three prioritized goals are administered. Added to these three items, a fourth item measures whether prioritization or goals have changed. If so, the participant is asked to state their new prioritization or goals, and the questions about the new goals are added in the subsequent measurements.

Time frame: Twice a week during phase A, up to 5 weeks; every other week during phase B, up to 8 months; weekly during phase C, 6 weeks

Change in Juvenile-Caregiver Conflict assessed by the Network of Relationship Inventory (NRI)

The NRI is a self-reported instrument for juveniles and caregivers. The NRI contains six items with possible scores ranging from 1 (not at all) to 100 (the most).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); twice a week during phase A, up to 5 weeks; every other week during phase B, up to 8 months; T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months; weekly during phase C, 6 weeks

Central Contacts

Marjolein van Cappellen

CONTACT

+31621944124 s.m.vancappellen@uu.nl

Jessica Asscher

CONTACT

+31624584734 j.j.asscher@uu.nl

Data from ClinicalTrials.gov

This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.

Secondary Outcomes

Change in Externalizing Behavior assessed by the Youth Self Report (YSR)

The YSR is a self-reported instrument. The Externalizing scale contains 30 items assessing aggression and delinquency. Possible scores range from 0 (never) to 2 (often).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Externalizing Behavior assessed with the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL)

The CBCL is a caregiver-reported instrument. The Externalizing scale contains 36 items assessing aggression and delinquency. Possible scores range from 0 (never) to 2 (often).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Delinquency assessed with the Self-Report Delinquent Behavior (SDB)

The SDB is a self-reported instrument, assessing how many times the juvenile has done certain (rule-breaking) things in the past year. The SDB contains 30 items.

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Percentage of Participants with Out of Home Placement assessed using File Analysis

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Percentage of Participants with Out of Home Placement assessed using an Out of Home Placement Questionnaire

A participant is viewed as being placed out of home when they do not reside with their primary family, either temporarily or permanently, and either voluntarily or involuntarily. Out of home placement will be assessed using a questionnaire measuring living situation, which is filled in by juveniles and caregivers. The questionnaire contains one item assessing where the juvenile lives most days of the week.

Time frame: T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Recidivism Risk assessed with the RAF GGZ Youth

The RAF GGZ Youth is an extensive risk assessment instrument and includes items measuring recidivism risk. The RAF GGZ Youth is filled in by the therapist as part of the standard FAST procedure. Possible scores range from 1 (low) to 5 (high).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Substance Use assessed with the Peilstation Middelengebruik

Peilstation Middelengebruik is a self-reported instrument. It contains five items assessing frequency and intensity of substance use.

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Substance Use assessed with the RAF GGZ Youth

The RAF GGZ Youth is an extensive risk assessment instrument and includes items measuring substance use. The RAF GGZ Youth is filled in by the therapist as part of the standard FAST procedure.

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Substance Use assessed with the FAST Goal list

The FAST Goals List is filled in by juveniles, caregivers, and therapists as part of the standard FAST procedure, and assess the achievement of FAST goals in the past two months. The list includes 1 item on change in substance use. Possible scores range from 1 (not true at all) to 10 (absolutely true).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Contact with Deviant Peers assessed with the Basic Peer Questionnaire (BPQ)

The BPQ is a self-reported instrument with 13 items. Possible scores differ per question, for instance measuring amount of friends, or 0 (never) to 4 (5 times or more).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Social Support assessed by the Parental Support Questionnaire (PSQ)

The PSQ is a caregiver self-reported instrument and contains 15 items. Possible scores range from 0 (no) to 1 (yes), and 1 (unsatisfied) to 5 (satisfied).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Caregiver-Adolescent Relationship Quality assessed by the Inventory of Parent and Peer Attachment (IPPA)

The IPPA is a juvenile self-reported instrument and contains 12 items per caregiver. Possible scores range from 1 (almost never) to 4 (almost always).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Caregiver-Adolescent Relationship Quality assessed by the Nijmeegse Parenting Stress Index (NPSI)

The NPSI is a caregiver self-reported instrument and contains nine items. Possible scores range from 1 (not applicable at all) to 6 (completely applicable).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Caregiver Consistency assessed by the Consistency Scale of the Parenting Dimensions Inventory (PDI)

The PDI is a juvenile and caregiver self-reported instrument. The Consistency scale contains eight items. Possible scores range from 1 (completely disagree) to 6 (completely agree).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Behavioral Control assessed by the Parenting Practices

The Parent Practices is a juvenile and caregiver self-reported instrument and contains six items. Possible scores range from 1 (never) to 5 (always).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Discipline Practices assessed by the Parenting Dimensions Inventory (PDI)

The PDI is a juvenile and caregiver self-reported instrument and contains three hypothetical situations with six items each. Possible scores range from 1 (very improbable) to 6 (very probable).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Psychological Control assessed by the Psychological Control Scale Youth Self-Report (PCS-YSR)

The PCS-YSR is a self-reported instrument and contains eight items. Possible scores range from 1 (not applicable at all) to 5 (completely applicable).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Caregiver Competence assessed by the Nijmeegse Parenting Stress Index (NPSI)

The NPSI is a caregiver self-reported instrument and contains 15 items. Possible scores range from 1 (completely disagree) to 6 (completely agree).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Parental Monitoring assessed by the Parental Monitoring Scale

The Parental Monitoring Scale is reported on by juveniles. It contains five items and one additional item measuring parental knowledge about school grades. Possible scores range from 1 (nothing) to 4 (everything).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Change in Cognitive Distortions assessed by the Brief Irrational Thoughts Inventory (BITI)

The BITI is a self-reported instrument and is filled in by juveniles as part of the standard FAST procedure. The BITI contains 18 items with possible scores range from 1 (completely disagree) to 6 (completely agree).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Demographics assessed by a Demographic Information Questionnaire

The Demographic information questionnaire contains items about gender, age, and occupation. The questionnaire contains nine items for juveniles, 19 for caregivers, and eight for therapists.

Time frame: T1 (baseline)

Primary Diagnosis assessed by Therapist File Search

The therapist file contains the primary diagnosis of the juvenile.

Time frame: T1 (baseline)

Change in Personality assessed by the Inventory of Callous-Unemotional Traits (ICU)

The ICU is reported by juveniles and caregivers and contains 24 items. Possible scores range from 1 (completely untrue) to 4 (always true).

Time frame: T1 (baseline)

Change in Personality assessed by the Narcissism and Impulse Control scales of the Antisocial Process Screening Device (APSD)

The APSD is reported by juveniles and caregivers. The scales contain 12 items for juveniles and 16 items for caregivers. Possible scores range from 1 (completely true) to 4 (always true).

Time frame: T1 (baseline)

Caregiver Psychopathology assessed by the RAF GGZ Youth

The RAF GGZ Youth is an extensive risk assessment instrument and includes items measuring caregiver psychopathology. The RAF GGZ Youth is filled in by the therapist as part of the standard FAST procedure. Possible scores range from 0 (problems not present) to 2 (problems definitely present).

Time frame: T1 (baseline)

Treatment Integrity assessed by the FAST Evaluation Forms

The FAST evaluation forms are filled in by juveniles, caregivers, and therapists as part of the standard FAST procedure. Possible scores range from 0 (no) to 1 (yes), and 1 (very bad, never) to 10 (very good, always).

Time frame: T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months from baseline

Treatment Completion assessed by Therapist File Search

Treatment completion will be assessed by coding whether FAST completion was registered as positive or negative.

Time frame: T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months from baseline

Treatment Duration assessed by Therapist File Search

Treatment duration will be calculated based on the registered direct treatment time by therapists in their appointment agendas. Treatment duration will be measured in weeks.

Time frame: T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months from baseline

Treatment Intensity assessed by Therapist File Search

Treatment intensity will be calculated based on the registered direct treatment time by therapists in their appointment agendas. Treatment intensity will be measured in average hours of direct treatment time per week.

Time frame: T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months from baseline

Therapist-Client Alliance assessed by the Relationship with Interventionist

The Relationship with Interventionist is a juvenile and caregiver self-reported instrument and contains 12 items. Possible scores range from 1 (completely disagree) to 6 (completely agree).

Time frame: T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months from baseline

Change in Treatment Motivation assessed by the Treatment Motivation Scales for Forensic Outpatient Treatment (TMS-F)

The TMS-F is reported on by juveniles and caregivers and contains 16 items. Possible scores range from 1 (completely disagree) to 5 (completely agree).

Time frame: T1 (baseline); T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months

Treatment Expectancies assessed by the Parent Expectancies for Therapy Scale (PETS)

The PETS is a caregiver self-reported instrument and contains seven items. Possible scores range from 1 (completely disagree) to 5 (completely agree).

Time frame: T1 (baseline)

Treatment Cooperation assessed by the Cooperation Scale

The Cooperation Scale is reported on by juveniles, caregivers, and therapists and contains five items. Possible scores range from 1 (completely disagree) to 6 (completely agree).

Time frame: T2 (post-intervention) up to 9 months from baseline