Clavicle fractures are a common orthopedic injury and make up 2.6%-5% of all fractures. Despite the benefits of operative management, post-operative chest wall paresthesia is a well-known complication among surgeons and is well described in the literature. Studies reporting on the natural history of post-operative paresthesia report an incidence of chest wall numbness anywhere from 10-80% and this is attributed to iatrogenic injury of the branches of the supraclavicular nerve that provide sensation over the clavicle, anteromedial shoulder and proximal chest. While this may seem like an easy complication to avoid, anatomic studies give insight into the complex and unpredictable branching of the supraclavicular nerve. The aim of this study was to compare the area (cm2) and change in size over time of post-operative paresthesia (includes hypesthesia and dysesthesia) following ORIF of displaced clavicle fractures between nerve-sacrificing and nerve-preserving procedures.
This is a prospective, partially-blinded, single center, randomized controlled trial to compare the post-operative outcomes of paresthesias and morbidity between nerve-preserving and nerve-sacrificing procedures after surgical fixation of clavicle fractures. Although prior studies explore different incision orientation, most fail to specify whether or not the supraclavicular nerve branches were identified and protected and also lack a patient questionnaire that focuses on paresthesia characteristics and patient quality of life as it relates to the measured area of postoperative numbness. In this proposed study, the investigators will be able to fill this gap in knowledge and give insight into whether or not a nerve-sparing technique should be used to decrease the morbidity of postoperative chest wall paresthesia following operative fixation of clavicle fractures. This research will be important to the scientific community because it will help guide a physician's pre-operative counseling and establish realistic expectations for their patients. It could also guide a physician's surgical technique in a manner to decrease post-operative morbidity for patient's undergoing surgical fixation of clavicle fractures. 1. Group 1 - Operative treatment utilizing a supraclavicular nerve-sacrificing procedure 2. Group 2 - Operative treatment utilizing a supraclavicular nerve-preserving procedure
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
SINGLE
Enrollment
45
Surgical fixation of the clavicle fracture will be performed through a horizontal incision over the clavicle. During the incision and soft tissue dissection, the surgeon will not attempt to identify the supraclavicular nerve branches. Instead, the surgeon will cut the nerve branches during the dissection.
Surgical fixation of the clavicle fracture will be performed through the same horizontal incision over the clavicle. The surgeon will attempt to dissect out, identify and preserve all branches of the supraclavicular nerve throughout the fracture reduction, fixation and closure.
Paresthesia mapping
A trained research fellow will be blinded to the operative intervention performed and will measure the area of chest wall paresthesia using a transparency grid made up of 1cmx1cm squares. The transparency grid will be placed over the patient's clavicle and the patient will be instructed to palpate the chest wall for areas of paresthesia. The examiner will then outline the area of paresthesia by tracing it onto the transparency slide.
Time frame: Each follow-up visit at 2 weeks post-operative, 12 weeks post-operative, 6 months post-operative, 1 year post-operative
Cutaneous Hyperesthesia/dysesthesia mapping
A 10 gram Semmes-Weinstein monofilament will be applied twice, for 1 second at each point as indicated on the diagram in Appendix E. It will be applied to two points at the medial 1/3, middle 1/3 and lateral 1/3 of the subclavicular region, 3cm distal the inferior border of the clavicle at each point. The monofilament will be applied twice for 1 second at each point. Unperceived points will be identified and recorded based on location at medial, middle or lateral 1/3. If this monofilament test results in dysesthesia (pain, tingling, shock like sensations), this will be recorded similarly.
Time frame: Each follow-up visit at 2 weeks post-operative, 12 weeks post-operative, 6 months post-operative, 1 year post-operative
Patient Morbidity
The research fellow will administer the Patient Morbidity questionnaire and record the patient's responses. This outlines the characteristics of the paresthesia and the effect on the patient. This will be the investigator's measure of patient-reported morbidity.
Time frame: Prior to measuring the area of paresthesia each follow-up visit at 2 weeks post-operative, 12 weeks post-operative, 6 months post-operative, 1 year post-operative
Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand (DASH); A 30-item self-reported questionnaire in which the response options are presented as 5-point Likert scales. Scores range from 0 (no disability) to 100 (most severe disability).
The patient will fill out the Disability of Arm, Shoulder \& Hand questionnaire as a measure of functional outcome.
Time frame: Prior to measuring the area of paresthesia each follow-up visit at 2 weeks post-operative, 12 weeks post-operative, 6 months post-operative, 1 year post-operative
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.