Prognostic Value of High-resolution Electrical Source Imaging on the Success of Pediatric Focal Epilepsy Surgery

Overview

This study investigates the usefulness of high resolution electrical source imaging (HR-ESI) in the setting of presurgical evaluation of drug-resistant focal epilepsy in children. This method is based on an estimation of the intra-cerebral source that produces a signal recorded by scalp electrodes by solving the inverse problem, taking into account attenuation factors resulting from particular conductivity properties of the cerebral, peri-cerebral and cranial tissues. Electrical sources are then fused on structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Scalp EEG recorded using 64 to 256 electrodes refers to as high resolution EEG (HR-EEG), leading to HR-ESI. Studies based on small population of children or on mixt population of children and adults showed that HR-ESI has accuracy values, i.e. percentage of true positives (electrical source localized in the brain area resected and success of surgery) and true negatives (electrical source localized outside the brain area resected and failure of surgery) among the total population, ranging from 50 to 80%. Discrepancies between studies could be explained by the limited number of patients included or by the mixture of pediatric and adult data. Another limitation of previously published studies is that the spatial pattern of dipole source distribution was not taken into account to determine prediction accuracy of ESI. Studies using magnetoencephalography (MEG) to perform magnetic source imaging (MSI) suggest that the spatial pattern of dipole source distribution needs to be considered, a spatially-restricted dipole distribution being associated with better post-surgical outcome when resected. To tackle these issues, the investigators aim to conduct the first large prospective multicentric study in children with focal epilepsy candidates to surgery to assess prediction accuracy of ESI based on the finding of tight clusters of dipoles. This is original as this pattern (tight versus loose cluster of dipoles) has been studied by several researchers using MEG but not using HR-EEG. The investigators make the hypothesis that HR-EEG will allow to identity good candidates for epilepsy surgery and thus to offer this underutilized treatment in more children with better post-surgical outcome. Among the secondary objectives, the investigators will address methodological issues related to the resolution of the inverse problem (methods using distributed sources models versus methods based on equivalent dipole estimation), the potential added value to model high-frequency oscillations (HFO), and the investigators will assess the cost-utility of the HR-ESI procedure.

This study investigates the usefulness of high resolution electrical source imaging (HR-ESI) in the setting of presurgical evaluation of drug-resistant focal epilepsy in children. This method is based on an estimation of the intra-cerebral source that produces a signal recorded by scalp electrodes by solving the inverse problem, taking into account attenuation factors resulting from particular conductivity properties of the cerebral, peri-cerebral and cranial tissues. Electrical sources are then fused on structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Scalp EEG recorded using 64 to 256 electrodes refers to as high resolution EEG (HR-EEG), leading to HR-ESI. Studies based on small population of children or on mixt population of children and adults showed that HR-ESI has accuracy values, i.e. percentage of true positives (electrical source localized in the brain area resected and success of surgery) and true negatives (electrical source localized outside the brain area resected and failure of surgery) among the total population, ranging from 50 to 80%. Discrepancies between studies could be explained by the limited number of patients included or by the mixture of pediatric and adult data. Another limitation of previously published studies is that the spatial pattern of dipole source distribution was not taken into account to determine prediction accuracy of ESI. Studies using magnetoencephalography (MEG) to perform magnetic source imaging (MSI) suggest that the spatial pattern of dipole source distribution needs to be considered, a spatially-restricted dipole distribution being associated with better post-surgical outcome when resected. To tackle these issues, the investigators aim to conduct the first large prospective multicentric study in children with focal epilepsy candidates to surgery to assess prediction accuracy of ESI based on the finding of tight clusters of dipoles. This is original as this pattern (tight versus loose cluster of dipoles) has been studied by several researchers using MEG but not using HR-EEG. The investigators make the hypothesis that HR-EEG will allow to identity good candidates for epilepsy surgery and thus to offer this underutilized treatment in more children with better post-surgical outcome. Among the secondary objectives, the investigators will address methodological issues related to the resolution of the inverse problem (methods using distributed sources models versus methods based on equivalent dipole estimation), the potential added value to model high-frequency oscillations (HFO), and the investigators will assess the cost-utility of the HR-ESI procedure. The study focuses on epileptic children who are candidates to a procedure of epilepsy surgery aiming to make them seizure-free. The principle of epilepsy surgery is to remove the brain area that generates patient's seizures, i.e. the seizure onset zone (SOZ). Candidates are patients with focal seizures that do not completely respond to the medical treatment and impact their quality of life. This represents 5-10% of epileptic children. Pre-surgical evaluation of these patients consists to perform in a first step non-invasive methods aimed to localize the SOZ: video-EEG in order to characterize usual seizures of the patient and to record and localize interictal epileptiform discharges (IED), MRI to search for a structural epileptogenic lesion, and positron emission tomography (PET) with fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) to search for a brain area showing abnormal FDG uptake. After this so-called phase 1 work-up, the case is discussed in a multidisciplinary meeting, resulting in one of the 3 following decisions: (1) surgical resection when information from phase 1 is considered as sufficient, (2) continuation of the surgical process by performing a phase 2 evaluation, i.e. an invasive EEG recording using intracranial electrodes implanted by stereotaxy (SEEG), when information from phase 1 is considered as insufficient but made possible to pose a hypothesis regarding the localization of the SOZ, and (3) rejection for surgery. In children, epilepsy makes patient seizure-free in 60-80% of the cases. HR-ESI is a relatively new method that has been developed to localize non-invasively the SOZ with the hope to decrease the number of patients rejected for surgery or oriented to phase 2, and to increase the rate of success of epilepsy surgery.