Two-phase interventional non-inferiority trial (phase 1: at least 8 weeks of CPAP; phase 2: 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal) including 32 patients with moderate to severe OSA to compare the physiological consequences of a short-term CPAP withdrawal to the changes in previously untreated OSA. The trial has been designed as a validation of the CPAP-withdrawal model. Baseline in-laboratory sleep studies will be performed prior to CPAP initiation, after 6-8 weeks on CPAP (treatment effect) and following 2 weeks of CPAP therapy withdrawal (withdrawal effect, effect of OSA recurrence).
Background and Aim: Obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA) is a prevalent sleep-related breathing disorder. OSA is associated with daytime sleepiness, impaired quality of life, and adverse cardiovascular outcome. OSA can be effectively treated with nocturnal continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) that restores normal breathing during sleep by preventing upper airway collapse. However, many patients in whom treatment of OSA is indicated are not able to adhere to CPAP, and the consequences of untreated OSA seem to differ between OSA phenotypes. Therefore, treatment alternatives to CPAP and a better understanding of treatment implications in different phenotypes of OSA are important targets in this research field. Thus, effective and controlled study designs are needed to address these research questions. Conventional randomised controlled CPAP trials are limited by low CPAP adherence resulting in an underestimation of the treatment effect. In addition, the impracticability of withholding an effective treatment from symptomatic patients resulting in inclusion of less symptomatic and patients with less severe OSA has limited the conclusions from previous trials. The CPAP therapy withdrawal model was introduced to allow studying the pathophysiological consequences of OSA and treatment effects of CPAP in an effective and controlled way. Optimally treated patients previously diagnosed with OSA established on CPAP therapy are included and undergo a short-term therapy interruption. A therapy withdrawal results in recurrence of OSA and pathophysiological changes can be attributed to OSA in this controlled model. However, it is uncertain whether the consequences of OSA during a short-term CPAP therapy withdrawal are comparable to long-term consequences of untreated OSA. The aim of this two-phase interventional trial is to assess the effects of intermediate and long-term CPAP therapy as well as acute CPAP therapy withdrawal resulting in OSA recurrence compared to longstanding untreated OSA on cardiovascular and symptom outcomes in moderate and severe OSA. The objective is to study the comparability of conventional CPAP therapy trials with the CPAP withdrawal model in terms of evaluating relevant cardiovascular and patient-centred outcomes in OSA. The investigators hypothesise that the treatment effect of CPAP in previously treatment-naïve patients with OSA - if adherent to CPAP - will support the same conclusions on OSA pathophysiology and therapy effects as a short-term CPAP withdrawal in treatment-adherent patients having a recurrence of OSA in response to CPAP withdrawal and thus support the use of this effective CPAP withdrawal model to use as future study design in interventional trials in OSA. It is hypothesised that the CPAP withdrawal is non-inferior to conventional CPAP trials in studying the effect on blood pressure and OSA-symptoms.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
NA
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
NONE
Enrollment
36
Nocturnal continuous positive airway pressure therapy is the gold standard treatment for symptomatic OSA. It provides positive pressure via a nasal or oronasal mask to prevent upper airway collapse during sleep.
University Hospital Zurich
Zurich, Switzerland
Nocturnal systolic blood pressure
Ambulatory blood pressure monitoring (ABPM)
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Epworth Sleepines Scale Score (ESS)
Subjective sleepiness, ESS min-max 0-24 points and ESS \>10 indicating pathological daytime sleepiness
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
48h, 24h, diurnal and nocturnal systolic and diastolic blood pressure
ABPM
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Office systolic and diastolic blood pressure
Morning office blood pressure
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
48h, 24h, diurnal, nocturnal and office heart rate
Heart rate from ABPM, office measurement and from sleep studies
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Heart rate variability in the time and frequency domain (CV, RMSSD, pRR50, LF, HF, LF/HF)
Measures of heart rate variability (daytime and nighttime)
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Blood pressure variability (BPV, systolic and diastolic)
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.
BPV from ABPM and beat-to-beat blood pressure measurement
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Baroreflex sensitivity (BRS)
Finometer
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Arterial stiffness
ABPM
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Measures of nocturnal hypoventilation (median and maximal transcutaneous partial pressure of CO2 = tcpCO2)
Sleep study parameters
Time frame: at baseline and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Measures of nocturnal hypoxaemia (mean nocturnal oxygen saturation = ¢SpO2)
Sleep study parameters
Time frame: at baseline and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Measures of nocturnal hypoxaemia (time spent with SpO2 below 90% = t<90)
Sleep study parameters
Time frame: at baseline and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Measures of nocturnal hypoxaemia (hypoxic burden)
Sleep study parameters
Time frame: at baseline and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Measures of OSA severity (apnoea-hypopnoea-index)
Sleep study parameters
Time frame: at baseline and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Measures of OSA severity (oxygen-desaturation index)
Sleep study parameters
Time frame: at baseline and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Sleepiness (Stanford Sleepiness Scale (SSS))
Questionnaire; 7-point Likert scale to quantify a patient's sleepiness at the time the questionnaire is completed; highr scores indicate more sleepiness
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Fatigue (fatigue severity scale (FSS))
Questionnaire; 9 items, higher score indicates more fatigue
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Disease-specific quality of life (Functional Outcomes of Sleep Questionnaire (FOSQ))
Questionnaires, Disease-specific quality of life questionnaire to determine functional status in adults; measures are designed to assess the impact of disorders of excessive sleepiness on multiple activities of everyday living and the extent to which these abilities are improved by effective treatment; 30 items; higher scores are better
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Superoxide dismutase
Marker of oxidative stress (U/ml)
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Urinary catecholamines
Epinephrine and norepinephrine in morning urine (nnmol/mmol)
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Pulse rise index (>6 beats per minute)
from nocturnal oximetry
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal
Nocturnal oxymetry measures (¢SpO2, t<90, ODI-3%, ODI-4%)
nocturnal pulse oximetry
Time frame: at baseline and at 2 and at least 8 weeks of CPAP as well as after 1 and after 2 weeks of CPAP withdrawal