Vegetarian Versus Non Vegetarian Based Diet in the Recurrence of Hepatic Encephalopathy in Patients With Cirrhosis: An Open Label Pilot Study

Overview

Earlier protein restriction was advocated in the treatment of HE but later this concept was refuted and increase protein intake was advocated in patients with HE. Diet in patients during an episode HE is also not known. It is advisable based on many case reports or case series that vegetable-based diet during the episode of HE is better than animal-based diet as it reduces ammonia level and other false neurotransmitters in brain and helps in early recovery of, HE . However, diet in patients who had recovered from an episode of, HE is not known and what type of protein (vegetarian or non-vegetarian) should be taken to prevent another episode of HE has never been evaluated. In India majority of the patients are vegetarian and patients with cirrhosis are malnourished and lack protein in their diet as per our previous published study

Hepatic encephalopathy (HE) is a neurological complication in cirrhosis and affects 30-80% of these patients. Patient conscious level varies from minimal altered sensorium to deep coma and hence it is classified into two categories, covert HE and overt HE. Its occurrence in patients with cirrhosis merits liver transplantation and it reduces survival rate to 50% in next 1-2 year. HE significantly affects quality of life, inability to drive, morbidity and mortality . Recovery from single episode of HE merits secondary prophylaxis with lactulose and rifaximin . Protein calorie malnutrition is also common in patients with cirrhosis and its prevalence varies from 30-90% depending upon the method of evaluation and types of patients enrolled . Sarcopenia negatively affects survival and can be precipitated by repeated episodes of admission and HE in patients with cirrhosis. Earlier protein restriction was advocated in the treatment of HE but later this concept was refuted and increase protein intake was advocated in patients with HE . Diet in patients during an episode HE is also not known. It is advisable based on many case reports or case series that vegetable-based diet during the episode of HE is better than animal-based diet as it reduces ammonia level and other false neurotransmitters in brain and helps in early recovery of, HE . However, diet in patients who had recovered from an episode of, HE is not known and what type of protein (vegetarian or non-vegetarian) should be taken to prevent another episode of HE has never been evaluated. In India majority of the patients are vegetarian and patients with cirrhosis are malnourished and lack protein in their diet as per our previous published study . We wish to study effect of diet on the recurrence of HE in patient with cirrhosis who had recovered completely from an episode of HE and are on secondary prophylaxis of HE. Materials and methods: Consecutive patients with cirrhosis who have recovered from an episode of HE will be screened and enrolled in the study if fulfilling the enrolment criteria. Cirrhosis will be diagnosed based on clinical, radiological, Transient elastography and biopsy if available. All relevant investigation will be done to evaluate the cause of cirrhosis (Viral markers, autoimmune markers etc). HE will be diagnosed based on West Heaven criteria and recovery will be assessed by the senior Consultant of this study. All patient will undergo handgrip strength test to assess muscle strength, number connection test and critical flicker frequency test to assess minimal hepatic encephalopathy at baseline and at 1,3 and 6 month interval. Handgrip test: This is a simple bed side test non-invasive tests in which patient will sit on a chair and held a instrument and press it as hard as possible after a training session to get the muscle strength. Its value will be recorded (26). Number connection test: It is simple bed side paper and pencil tests.In a paper numbers are written from 1 to 25 in a random session and patient will join the number as fast as possible and result will be recorded(4) Critical flicker frequency tests: It is again a simple bed side test in which patient will see an instrument and a light source. Patient will see the flickering of light and he will record it by pushing a button. Its value will be recorded(27). Blood tests which includes complete blood count,liver and kidney function tests,INR will be assessed at baseline,1,3 and 6 month as per standard practise in these patients. Assessment of dietary intake All patients will be assessed by investigator and trained dietician for the calculation of total calories, carbohydrates, protein and fat by 24 recall method. Assessment of these parameters will be compared as per standard recommendation by INASL guidelines(10). If patient is taking less calories or proteins, these will be supplemented according to patient choice of food and as per standard guidelines. Vegetarian subjects: Protein will be supplemented as per recommendation 1.5 gm/kg body weight and it will be supplemented with vegetable source. Milk and milk products are allowed in this group as most of the Indians who are vegetarian also consume milk and milk products. Egg and meat products are not allowed. Non vegetarian subjects: Protein will be supplemented by both vegetarian and non-vegetarian diet. Patients will be encouraged to take more\>50% of total daily protein requirement as non-vegetarian based protein which will include eggs and meat products. Due to cultural belief in India people do not take non vegetarian food on daily basis. Patients will maintain a dairy of their daily protein source. If patient is taking less than 50% of his daily protein from non-vegetarian source for more than 10 days per month these patients will be taken as non-compliant and will be recorded. Randomisation protocol: This will be an open label study and patients will be divided into two groups based on their dietary pattern previous to enrolling in this study. Patients who are strict vegetarian will be grouped into vegetarian group and patients who are non vegetarian will be given a choice to enrol in any group and will be randomised accordingly. Follow up protocol: All patients will be followed by the investigator at baseline, fifteen days and then at one month interval for 6 months from day of enrolment in the study. All patients are free to come to hospital at any time in case of any medical issue and will be assessed as per standard protocol. All patients will be managed as per standard practise and all previous medications like beta blockers, diuretics, antiviral therapy, lactulose and rifaximin will be continued if taking. Patient on secondary prophylaxis for HE with lactulose with or without rifaximin will continue the medications. Management of Hepatic encephalopathy: All patients will be managed as per standard protocol with correction of precipitating factors, lactulose, L ornithine L aspartate infusion or sachets and rifaximin. Patients with more than grade 2 encephalopathy will be admitted Statistical methods: The results of this study will be expressed as mean± standard error. The p value of \< 0.05 will be considered statistically significant. Data will be compared using the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test for continuous data and Fisher test for categorical data. Comparisons of the variables will be performed using the Wilcoxon test and Fisher test as needed. Statistical analyses of the data will be performed by using SPSS 23 Statistical Software (SPSS Inc. and Microsoft Corp., Chicago, IL).