This study aims to evaluate whether the reduction of the daily morphine equivalent dose (MED) in patients with chronic non-cancer pain (CNCP) can be decreased with an open-label placebo (OLP) intervention in comparison to an electronic monitoring (EM) control group. The participants will receive the intervention (OPL or EM) over the duration of six weeks. Diverse psychological and health measures will be assessed with questionnaires over the course of the intervention. Furthermore, evaluation outcomes, qualitative outcomes and safety outcomes will be assessed. It is hypothesized that the OLP-intervention group in comparison to the EM-control group will have a significantly lower consumption of MED over the course of the study. Furthermore, this study aims to evaluate whether the OLP intervention can reduce opioid withdrawal symptoms in comparison to the control group.
CNCP is a major global health problem and is often treated with opiod medication, although risks outweigh the benefits. Therefore, recent studies suggest that an open-label placebo (OLP) treatment, the placebo treatment with full disclosure of being a placebo, has proven to be an effective, clinically relevant, and evidence-based treatment in CNCP syndromes. Furthermore, a new line of research indicated that OLPs have been shown to be feasible for the reduction of active medication in opioid use disorder. In line with the conditioning paradigm, the drug as the unconditioned stimulus is paired with the neutral stimulus of an OLP in a learning phase. Then, the OLP alone becomes a conditioned stimulus.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
NONE
Enrollment
86
In the intervention group, open-label placebos are administered within the framework of a mind-body management intervention approach, which in turn is consistent with the biopsychosocial model of pain and with a patient-centred approach. The verbal interaction follows the four discussion points: 1. Opioids work by telling the body that participants are not experiencing as much pain; 2. Placebos should be taken every time an opioid is taken which supports the reduction of opioid medication (shown by previous studies); 3. By pairing the pills together the brain will learn to release chemicals like endorphins that cause pain-relief in response to the placebo, just as it does in response to the opioid; 4. At a certain point, placebos might provide adequate pain relief, and the participants might need less opioids.
In the EM control group, the focus lies on the electronic monitoring (EM) of the opioid intake. The treatment rationale is designed to facilitate the reduction of opioid medication by promoting a positive attitude towards the implementation of the reduction. The verbal interaction follows the four discussion points: 1. The collection of EM data allows for greater patients' sense of agency over medication treatment; 2. Tracking of opioid medication use supports the reduction of opioid medication (shown by previous studies); 3. The EM is a useful tool, and daily recording of opioid medication intake should be done; 4. At a certain point, EM might provide adequate pain relief, and participants might need less opioids.
University Hospital Zurich, Department of Consultation-Liaison Psychiatry and Psychosomatic Medicine
Zurich, Canton of Zurich, Switzerland
RECRUITINGDaily opioid consumption (MED):
Cumulative dose (i.e. total amount) of opioid pain medication consumption based on daily morphine equivalent doses (MED). Data is collected in SEMA3 app.
Time frame: Daily measure: starts on day 1 after the first intervention visit (baseline, day 0) after randomization and ends on day 42 at the end of the study.
Subjective opioid withdrawal symptoms
Subjective opioid withdrawal will be assessed with the Subjective Opiate Withdrawal Scale (SOWS). The intensity of the withdrawal symptoms is rated by the patient on a scale between 0 (= not at all) and 4 (= extremely), the scores for individual symptoms are added to a total sum score, which can range from 0 to 64. The secondary endpoint will be the subjective opioid withdrawal score at study end (t3).
Time frame: Measured three times: on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline), on day 7, and on day 42 at the end of the study.
Pain severity
Pain severity is assessed using the ICD-11 specifiers or 'extension codes'. The index combines patient-assessed ratings of pain intensity, pain-related distress and pain-related interference. Each of these ratings is assessed on an 11-point NRS rating scale, and these are mapped into the following categories depending on the NRS score: none = NRS 0, mild = NRS 1 - 3, moderate = NRS 4 - 6 and severe = NRS 7 - 10.
Time frame: Measured three times: on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline), on day 7, and at the end of the study on day 42.
Pain disability
Pain disability is assessed using the pain disability index (PDI) to determine the subjective degree of self-reported impairment caused by the pain problem in everyday life. Seven domains of life are assessed: (1) family and domestic responsibilities, (2) recreation, (3) social activities, (4) occupation, (5) sexual life, (6) self-care and (7) essential activities. The scale ranges from 0 "no impairment" (minimum) - 10 "full impairment" (maximum).
Time frame: Measured three times: on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline), on day 7, and at the end of the study on day 42.
Anxiety
Anxiety is assessed using the German version of the GAD-7. It is a brief instrument for assessing self-reported generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) symptoms with seven items asking about the main diagnostic criteria of GAD according to the DSM-IV and the ICD-10 criteria. The questions refer to the past two weeks. The scale ranges from "not at all" (minimum); "On some days"; "On more than half of the days"; "almost every day" (maximum).
Time frame: Measured three times: on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline), on day 7, and at the end of the study on day 42.
Depression
Depression is assessed using Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-D) consisting of nine items referring to the past two weeks. The German version of the PHQ was derived from the 'Prime MD Patient Health Questionnaire' and is based on the criteria of the DSM-IV. The scale ranges from "not at all" (minimum); "On some days"; "On more than half of the days"; "almost every day" (maximum).
Time frame: Measured three times: on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline), on day 7, and at the end of the study on day 42.
Pain Opioid Analgesics Beliefs Scale - Cancer
The POABS-CA in the German version measures pain opioid beliefs based on two components with 10 items and a 5-point Likert scale ranging from 0 ("strongly disagree") to 4 ("strongly agree"). The higher the score, the more negative was the opinion about the use of opioid analgesics for cancer pain, and the stronger was the belief that pain should be endured.
Time frame: Measured three times: on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline), on day 7, and at the end of the study on day 42.
Treatment Expectancy 1
Expectation measures will be measured in analogy to the most relevant outcomes. First, subjectively expected amount (dose) of opioid medication taken will be examined. For this, the following item will be used at the end of the study "How much opioid medication do you think you will be taking at the end of the study?" The item is answered by naming the type of medication, frequency and amount (dose) of medication.
Time frame: One-time assessment: measured on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline).
Treatment Expectancy 2
Expectation measures will be measured in analogy to the most relevant outcomes. Second, to measure the expected withdrawal symptoms at the end of the study, items from the SOWS questionnaire will be used, which are expanded with instructions regarding the expectation.
Time frame: One-time assessment: measured on day 0 at the first intervention visit (baseline).
Placebo pill count
The intake of placebo pills by the OLP-group will be electronically monitored using survey provided by the app SEMA3. For statistical analysis a ratio will be calculated. A value of the ration close to 1 indicated a more accurate data entry of the placebo pill intake.
Time frame: Daily measure: starts 1 day after the first intervention visit (baseline, day 0) after randomization and ends on day 42 at the end of the study.
Opioid adherence
Opioid adherence trajectories will be measured with the app SEMA3 in both groups. In the EM control group, a print of the actual data report from the app (i.e. graph reflecting the pattern of opioid medication intake) will be the basis for the EM-Feedback.
Time frame: Daily measure: starts 1 day after the first intervention visit (baseline, day 0) after randomization and ends on day 42 at the end of the study.
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.