Testing a Novel Barrier Cream for Fecal Incontinence in an Ambulatory Population

Overview

Liquid stool and diarrhea are associated with an increased risk for moisture-associated skin damage (MASD), and clinical evidence suggests that exposure to liquid stool is associated with severe MASD and extensive erosion of affected skin. There are no known products on the market that treat fecal incontinence or MASD caused by fecal enzyme activity. Scotiaderm has invented a novel barrier cream (Dermategrity Everyday Barrier Cream) with an enhanced formula containing zinc oxide and soybean extract that inhibits fecal enzymes to protect the skin while preventing further breakdown. Dermategrity Everyday Barrier Cream has shown superior outcomes in comparison to zinc oxide alone in simulated laboratory testing, and promising results have been obtained in clinical case studies. To date, however, there has been no formal clinical testing of this new barrier product in comparison to standard zinc oxide creams. The purpose of this study is to perform a randomized, controlled clinical study comparing Dermategrity Everyday Barrier Cream to zinc oxide barrier cream to determine if there is a difference in healing, clinical outcomes, and the speed of resolution of MASD symptoms between groups, in an ambulatory patient population.

Moisture associated skin damage (MASD) is a grouping of painful, irritating rashes which occur when a patient has repeated or prolonged exposure to moisture from perspiration, urine and/or feces. Commonly encountered rashes in this group include incontinence-associated dermatitis (IAD) and intertrigo (ITD). These conditions can affect as many as one in five hospitalized patients and up to 50% of intensive care unit patients, putting them at risk of skin breakdown, serious infection, and the development of pressure ulcers. MASD is a common but overlooked and under-reported skin care problem, and there are many gaps in the knowledge of how best to treat these rashes. Liquid stool and diarrhea are associated with an increased risk for MASD when fecal materials remain in contact with the skin for a prolonged period. Diarrhea is associated with an increased likelihood of IAD in children, and clinical evidence suggests that exposure to liquid stool is associated with severe MASD and extensive erosion of affected skin. Liquid stool is also rich with coliform bacteria, and the gastrointestinal tract acts as a reservoir for various fungal species including Candida, which commonly complicates IAD. Liquid stool contains higher concentrations of proteolytic enzymes with the potential to impair the moisturizing effects of proteins such as filaggrin, and the softening effects of the intrinsic lipids in the skin, both of which are vital in maintaining the barrier functions in skin. These effects are exacerbated by a more alkaline pH and the higher concentrations of active fecal enzymes associated with diarrhea. Research on incontinent patients in the intensive care unit shows that the mean time to development of MASD is 4 days. The presence of liquid stool is an independent risk factor for the development of IAD, with patients developing IAD at a rate of 1.5x that of patients who are continent. The current standard of care for the treatment and prevention of MASD involves a structured skin care regiment that involves cleansing of the skin to remove excessive moisture and irritants with a pH balanced cleanser, moisturizing the skin when indicated and applying a protective productive product when repeated exposure to moisture is anticipated. There are many factors that influence the choice of moisturizers and protective products, however a Cochrane review of IAD in 2016 noted that there was no evidence that one product was superior to another. Currently, a single-step intervention using disposable washcloths that incorporate cleansing, protecting, and skin restoring agents into a single product (3-in-1 wipes) is widely practiced and helps to maximize adherence to best practices in the treatment and prevention of MASD. Research has shown that a family of enzyme inhibitors can be isolated from a subset of plants. These plant-based inhibitor peptides (PBIPs) have been well characterized and have been shown to reduce the proteolytic activities of enzymes commonly seen in the digestive tract and feces. PBIPs have demonstrated anticarcinogenic activity against tumor cells in vitro, in animal models, and in human phase II clinical trials. PBIP Concentrates (PBIPCs) have the same anticarcinogenic profile as purified PBIPs and have been developed for human trials. Both PBIPs and PBIPCs are nontoxic, and safety has been reported in numerous clinical studies. Topical PBIPCs have been used safely in clinical studies as hair growth suppressant and to treat skin pigmentation. Scotiaderm Inc. has developed Dermategrity Everyday Barrier Cream; a topical formulation of a barrier cream containing zinc oxide with PBIPCs from soybeans to be used in the treatment of MASD caused by diarrhea and/or fecal incontinence. The purpose of the proposed research is to evaluate the safety, efficacy, and patient satisfaction with Dermategrity Everyday Barrier Cream for the treatment of Moisture Associated Skin Damage (MASD) caused by fecal incontinence in an outpatient setting. The study design will compare a standard barrier cream for MASD (15% zinc oxide barrier cream) to Scotiaderm's proprietary formula (3% soybean extract in 15% zinc oxide barrier cream) to determine if the plant-based extract enhances the efficacy of treatment. This is a single center, randomized, double-blind, controlled study. This study will follow 40 patients from the wound clinic at the University of Calgary who present with IAD from diarrhea and/or fecal incontinence. The primary outcomes are the change in erythema score and the patient severity of symptoms score on the GLOBIAD, and patient-reported symptoms on a VAS scale from baseline to days seven and fourteen of treatment. Secondary outcomes will be product-related adverse events, patient-reported satisfaction with the product, and patient-reported healing. Patients will be followed for two weeks, with a baseline/enrollment visit and follow-up visits occurring on day seven and day fourteen. Both the clinical care team and the patients will be blinded to their group assignment. The research coordinator will provide the clinical team with a plain tube of barrier cream and an envelope outlining the treatment protocol for the study arm the patient has been assigned. The study product will be shipped with the product labels included and these labels will be kept on file by the study coordinator for reference as needed. For all applications the patient (or their personal care aid) will apply the treatment themselves, with instructions provided to patients at the baseline visit. Between study visits, patients will complete a daily symptoms journal with three VAS questions for pain, itching and burning, record the number of bowel movements/day, as well as note any other relevant symptoms or comments regarding their assigned treatment or their MASD. On days seven and fourteen, patients will present to the clinic for an assessment from the investigator on the status of their rash, which will include completion of the Global IAD Assessment and a VAS Erythema score. Any adverse events or unexpected side effects experienced by the participant will be recorded by the research team during clinic visits and reviewed by the investigator. Patients are instructed to contact the research team immediately if they experience any serious health issues during use of the study product. Participants will be asked to complete the daily symptom journal for two weeks while participating in the study, and to bring the journal with them to their follow-up visits. For any days that patients report less than 2 applications of the cream, they will be asked to explain why the minimum dosage was not met. On their final visit on day fourteen, patients will return their journal to the study team, and the final clinical assessment will be completed. Patients will be asked to fill out a questionnaire on their satisfaction with the cream used and their opinion on how effective it was at relieving symptoms and treating their rash. Patients will be unblinded once all study activities have been completed. The primary analysis will focus on the patient severity of symptoms from the Global IAD, the Erythema score, and the patient-reported VAS scores. A repeated measures ANOVA will be used to compare outcomes across time points for each of the independent variables. Efficacy will be assessed by quantifying the change in VAS scores from day 0 to day 7 and day 14. Safety will be assessed by documenting any adverse events/reactions that occur to patients participating in this study. Patient satisfaction with the product will be captured via a standard questionnaire at the conclusion of the study. It is hypothesized that Dermategrity Everyday Barrier Cream containing will demonstrate an excellent patient-reported safety profile and higher reported rate of healing of MASD due to diarrhea and/or fecal incontinence compared to the standard of care over a two-week period. Furthermore, it is hypothesized that patients will have high satisfaction with the study product.