How Exercise, a Controlled Diet and Education Improve the Health of People with Early-Stage Renal Failure: A Study at Ciudad Guzmán Hospital
Chronic kidney disease has a high mortality rate per year, which has led to the search for different intervention strategies to improve adherence to treatment and the promotion of healthy behaviors such as diet and exercise. The latter has been little explored in early stages (G1 and G2) even though its implementation can have an impact on the biochemical parameters of patients and delay their progression. Exercise represents a non-pharmacological, non-invasive, and cost-effective method in health promotion, as it can reduce biomarkers of inflammation such as C-reactive protein, interleukin-6, tumor necrosis factor-α, among others. Despite this, statistics show that 27% of adults in the world do not do the 150 minutes of exercise per week recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO). Regarding medical indications for exercise, there is a prevailing resistance in the medical community regarding its recommendation, given that proteinuria and/or changes in blood pressure linked to this activity are considered to have an impact on renal function. Existing exercise recommendations and proposals are focused on patients on peritoneal dialysis or hemodialysis. One of the most widespread in this patient population are the recommendations made by the WHO for older people with chronic conditions, and more specifically, there are the kidney disease: Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) guidelines, however, both give general recommendations, and it has been pointed out as a point of opportunity to explore exercise in this population. The published interventions are limited and do not include biochemical parameters in most of them, nor the physical aptitudes of the patients when performing exercise. On the other hand, it has been identified that the reduction of complications in these patients is associated with healthy behaviors, such as exercise, greater adherence to diet and pharmacological treatment. Several structural barriers have been detected, such as ideological barriers, beliefs, access to treatments, among others, which influence patients' lack of adherence to the plans. Considering the above, the aim of the present research will be to analyze the effects of an exercise program and a protein-controlled diet using an educational intervention on biochemical parameters, muscle strength and body composition in patients with chronic kidney disease in stage G1 and G2. The intervention will be for 3 months and will have two groups: one will follow an exercise program designed for each participant; the second group will follow the exercise recommendation proposed by the KDIGO 2022 guidelines. Both groups will have a personalized dietary plan, educational sessions, body composition and muscle strength assessment monthly. Biochemical parameters such as: creatinine, cystatin C, glucose, urea, urinary sediment, among others, will be evaluated at the beginning and at the end of the intervention to compare changes. Regarding adherence to both the exercise program and the diet, we will seek to reduce the patients' structural barriers by means of educational sessions based on the health belief model (HBM). Topics such as: knowledge of the disease, culinary techniques, barriers that prevent adherence to treatment, among others, will be taught. This project is expected to generate novel knowledge regarding the impact of an educational intervention combined with exercise in patients with chronic kidney disease in early stages. This information may be relevant to guide recommendations in clinical practice guidelines, in addition to promoting the adoption of healthy behaviors such as structured exercise.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
PREVENTION
Masking
QUADRUPLE
Enrollment
15
Unlike other projects, this study focuses on an underexplored area in exercise and kidney disease research. Typically, exercise recommendations are directed toward individuals undergoing hemodialysis or peritoneal dialysis. However, in the early stages of the disease, when the kidneys begin to show alterations, there is no established safe training protocol as a preventive measure. This clinical trial will fill that gap by providing references for an exercise program specifically designed for individuals in the early stages of kidney disease. The main objective will be to compare two different exercise strategies to determine potential benefits for renal health.
Centro Universitario del Sur
Ciudad Guzmán, Jalisco, Mexico
RECRUITINGChanges in total cholesterol
Total cholesterol: A decrease in values is expected, taking as reference a normal range of \<200 mg/dL. This will indicate a better outcome of the intervention. A change obtained from week 1 to week 12 is expected.
Time frame: changes from baseline to week 12
Changes in HDL cholesterol
HDL cholesterol: An increase in its values is expected, with a normal range of \>40 mg/dL. The increase will mean better cardiovascular outcomes. Change is expected from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: Changes from baseline measurement to week 12
LDL cholesterol changes
LDL cholesterol: A reduction in its levels is expected, considering a reference value \<100 mg/dL. The decrease will mean better cardiovascular outcomes. Evaluation from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: Changes from basal levels up to week 12
Changes in triglycerides levels
Triglycerides: a decrease in values is expected, with a reference range \<150 mg/dL. The decrease will mean better cardiovascular outcomes
Time frame: Changes from baseline measurement to week 12
Changes in albumin level
Albumin: An increase in its values is anticipated, with a normal range of 3.5-5 g/dL. Its increase will be considered an adequate nutritional parameter and a decrease of inflammatory marker. Evaluation from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: Changes from baseline levels to week 12
Changes in vitamin D levels
Vitamina D (25-hidroxivitamina D o 25(OH)D): Se espera un aumento de los valores, tomando como referencia un rango de 30-50 ng/mL. Evaluación de la semana 1 a la semana 12.
Time frame: Changes from baseline levels at week 12
Changes in insulin levels
Insulin: Changes in its values will be analyzed, considering a reference range of 2-25 U/mL. Its increase will be considered a favorable result. Evaluation from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: Changes from baseline to week 12
Changes in Creatina fosfoquinasa (CK total)
Creatine Phosphokinase (Total CK): Values are expected to be maintained or increased as a result of adaptation to exercise, with a reference range of 26-192 U/L. Evaluation from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: Changes from baseline to week 12
Changes in the quality of life questionnaire KDQOL-SF
Kidney Disease Quality of Life: Improvements are expected in the questionnaire score, ranging from 0 (lowest quality of life) to 100 (highest quality of life). Assessment from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: Changes in initial (week 1) and final responses (week 12)
Changes in the answers to the questionnaire "Knowledge of the disease".
Questionnaire "Knowledge of the disease": The changes in the correct answers to the 13 items will be analyzed by means of a score based on the Likert scale. Evaluation from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: changes in initial (week 1) and final responses (week 12)
Changes in the answers to the questionnaire - Opinion on the disease
Opinión sobre la enfermedad: Se evaluarán los cambios en la percepción de los participantes sobre su enfermedad, determinando su grado de acuerdo o desacuerdo con diferentes afirmaciones.
Time frame: changes in initial (week 1) and final responses (week 12)
Adherence in exercise frequency
Exercise frequency: It will be measured by self-reporting, recording the number of weekly sessions and the duration of each one. A greater number of sessions will be considered a better indicator of results. Evaluation from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: initial changes (week 1) and final changes (week 12)
Changes in grip strength
Grasping grip strength (dynamometer): An increase in dominant hand grip strength, expressed in kilograms, is expected. Ideal values are \>25 kg, but in this population improvement over baseline measurement will be considered. Assessment from week 1 to week 12.
Time frame: changes from the baseline measurement (week 1) to the final week (week 12)
Changes in fat mass
Reduction of fat mass: It will be evaluated by electrical bioimpedance (InBody®), comparing the baseline measurement with the final measurement at week 12. A healthy body fat percentage will be taken as a reference point: ≤25% in women and ≤15% in men.
Time frame: Comparative changes from baseline (week 1) to final measurement (week 12)
Muscle mass changes
Increase in muscle mass: It will be analyzed through electrical bioimpedance (InBody®), considering an increase in relation to healthy reference values: ≥35% in men and ≥25% in women. Initial and final values (week 12) will be compared.
Time frame: Comparative changes from baseline (week 1) to final measurement (week 12)
Changes in body mass index
Body Mass Index (BMI): BMI changes in overweight patients will be evaluated, taking a healthy range of 20-25 kg/m² as a reference.
Time frame: Comparative changes from baseline (week 1) to final measurement (week 12)
Changes in the responses to the questionnaire "frequency of food consumption for the Mexican population"
Increase in fruit and vegetable foods and decrease in processed foods, evaluated with the food consumption frequency questionnaire for the Mexican population.
Time frame: changes in responses to the questionnaire "food consumption frequency for the mexican population" comparing initial (week 1) and final (week 12) responses
Changes in visceral fat
Changes in visceral fat measured from week 1 to week 12 by InBody bioimpedance scale.
Time frame: Changes from baseline measurement (week 1) to final measurement (week 12)
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.