Supervised Toothbrushing and Oral Health Education in Primary Schools in Saudi Arabia

Overview

The goal of this pilot study is to assess the feasibility of implementing school-based oral health programmes including supervised toothbrushing and oral health education. The main questions it aims to answer are: * Is it feasible to implement supervised toothbrushing and oral health education programmes in primary schools in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia? * What are the facilitators and barriers to implementation regarding programme acceptance, participation of school staff, and adherence to the supervision guidelines? * How do these programmes influence children's self-reported oral health status, risk behaviours, and quality of life during the study period? * What is the effect of these programmes on dental caries incidence, plaque and gingival bleeding scores over a one-year follow-up? Participants will: * Take part in either a supervised toothbrushing programme or an oral health education programme. * Undergo dental examinations at baseline and after one year of follow-up to assess changes in dental caries, and plaque and gingival bleeding scores.

Dental caries is one of the most widespread oral health diseases affecting populations worldwide, including Saudi Arabia. Several studies assessing dental caries prevalence in Saudi Arabia have revealed a tremendous increase in its prevalence among children over the last few decades. A systematic review examined the national prevalence of caries among Saudi schoolchildren from 1988 to 2010. The review revealed that dental caries is highly prevalent across Saudi Arabia, particularly in Riyadh City. The caries prevalence in primary teeth was approximately 80% with a mean dmft of 5.0, while in permanent teeth, the prevalence was estimated to be 70% with a mean DMF value of 3.5. A recent systematic review evaluated caries prevalence from 1999 to 2019. The results showed that the proportion level for caries among schoolchildren is high, ranging from 0.21 to 1.00 for primary teeth and from 0.05 to 0.99 for permanent teeth. This emphasises that dental caries remains a significant oral health issue in Saudi Arabia. In Riyadh city, several studies have consistently indicated a high prevalence of dental caries and DMFT values in children. A national study explored caries prevalence and severity among schoolchildren across Saudi Arabia. This study included a nationwide sample of 19,870 school students. The study found that 65.6% of examined children had caries, with a mean dmft of 3.93 ± 3.60 and a mean DMFT of 2.42 ± 2.52. It was observed that Riyadh City exhibited the highest rate of missing teeth at 10.2%. Despite the lower prevalence of caries reported in this study compared to previous studies, it remained higher than that reported in other countries, such as the United Kingdom, with a caries prevalence of 29.3% among 5-year-old children. This illustrates that caries continues to be a significant concern and the primary oral health issue among Saudi children. Implementation of oral health programmes in school settings is considered one of the most effective approaches for improving children's oral health, as they can reach many schoolchildren. The report titled "Oral Health Promotion: An Essential Element of a Health-Promoting School" recognised schools as an ideal environment for promoting oral health due to their significant impact on children's oral health status, knowledge, and behaviours. The report shed light on global evidence supporting the efficacy of oral health programmes in schools. It was noticed that countries adopting public health programmes, including school-based oral health programmes, have witnessed a reduction in caries prevalence. On the other hand, the caries prevalence in Saudi Arabia remains high. Over the years, the Saudi Ministry of Health has been active in promoting oral health and has implemented a range of oral health programmes to enhance oral health, control and prevent oral diseases, including dental caries. However, no consistent national oral health school-based programmes are implemented in Saudi Arabia. There is strong and sufficient evidence regarding the effectiveness of supervised toothbrushing with fluoride toothpaste on the oral health status of preschool and school children. A study evaluated evidence-based oral health promotion programmes. The findings indicated that supervised toothbrushing interventions have resulted in caries reductions of 40%. The author also reported that supervised toothbrushing interventions are cost-effective and more efficient when specifically targeted towards high-risk populations. The programmes that had the strongest evidence for preventing caries were implemented in Scotland, England, and Jordan. The study in Jordan, a country with a similar cultural background and social norms to Saudi Arabia. The programme lasted four years and involved daily supervised toothbrushing at school. The results showed that children in the supervised toothbrushing group exhibited better caries status and were up to 6 times less likely to have caries than the control group. A systematic review concluded that the effectiveness and benefits of using fluoridated toothpaste to prevent dental caries among children are well established. Research indicates that dental caries in primary dentition can progress rapidly over one year. Another systematic review revealed that 3.8% to 12.2% of children develop cavities in their primary teeth annually. The rapid progression of caries in primary teeth within a year, especially when using the WHO criteria that records only cavitated lesions, emphasises the importance of early detection and preventive measures to manage caries in primary dentition effectively. It is also worth noting that this quick progression of caries in the primary teeth will allow detection of changes in caries within one year. Supervised toothbrushing with fluoridated toothpaste can be effective in reducing this risk, as it helps in the early management of incipient caries, preventing their progression to cavitated lesions. A systematic review to evaluate the effectiveness of oral health promotion interventions among children found that interventions that include supervised toothbrushing with fluoridated toothpaste were more effective in preventing caries in primary teeth. Another review explored a range of school-based supervised toothbrushing programmes, concluding that children participating in toothbrushing interventions are most likely to have better oral hygiene practices, oral cleanliness, and gingival health. To date, no supervised toothbrushing programmes have been implemented in school settings in Saudi Arabia. Given the robust evidence of supervised toothbrushing and the high risk of dental caries among Saudi children, implementing this programme is expected to be an effective strategy for reducing caries. The evidence for the effectiveness of school-based oral health education programmes indicates that they yield positive outcomes for children's knowledge acquisition. There is some evidence on the effectiveness of integrating preschool and school-based supervised toothbrushing programmes with oral health education. A systematic review comprised four randomised controlled trials. Interventions included oral health education and supervised toothbrushing sessions. The authors reported limited evidence of these interventions on caries prevention; however, it was noted that they have a positive impact on plaque levels and children's knowledge. Three studies found a statistically significant reduction in plaque in the intervention groups compared to the control groups. According to a recent systematic review, oral health education sessions incorporated lectures, audiovisual aids, and activities effectively reduced plaque and bleeding scores, and enhanced the knowledge and behaviour of schoolchildren aged 6 to 12. Another recent systematic review showed that the oral health education interventions, such as oral health education "lectures, albums, slides, leaflets, counselling, games, drawings, theatre, dieting guidance, toothbrushing instructions, toothbrushing demonstration with models, and supervised toothbrushing, were significantly effective on schoolchildren's oral health status. A randomised controlled trial was conducted in 2022 to evaluate the effectiveness of oral health promotion programmes among 702 primary students in Sakaka, Saudi Arabia. The study demonstrated a significant reduction in dental caries, indicating that oral health education involving teachers with reinforcement sessions is an effective approach for improving the oral health of Saudi children. In addition, another study found that oral health education programmes in primary schools in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, positively impacted students' oral health knowledge and behaviours. Based on the previous evidence, oral health education sessions involving teachers may be applicable and effective for the Saudi population. Limited research has been conducted into the practical implementation of supervised toothbrushing programmes. A pilot study evaluated the feasibility of implementing preventive programmes, including fluoride varnish and toothbrushing programmes, among 3 to 7-year-old students in primary schools in London, UK. The findings showed that the toothbrushing programme was feasible to execute in schools and was accepted by all stakeholders, including parents, school staff and dental teams. The study discovered that appointing school staff in each school to lead the programme and facilitate communication contributes to its successful implementation. A recent pilot study examined the feasibility of conducting supervised toothbrushing and fluoride varnish programmes and their effects on dental caries in Derby City, England. The results indicated a decrease in dental caries and improvement in oral hygiene and dental attendance. Frequently reported Facilitators to supervised toothbrushing implementation include programme flexibility, school staff positive attitudes, community volunteer involvement, and the development of toothbrushing habits. In the context of Saudi Arabia, the majority of participating teachers expressed interest in oral health education programmes and supported their inclusion in the curriculum. Rationale for the study The high prevalence of caries in Saudi Arabia and its impact on general health make it increasingly important to establish effective preventive oral health measures. The WHO recommended conducting oral health programmes to improve children's oral health in school settings. Unfortunately, most Saudi children are at high risk for dental caries. Even with the nationwide oral health programmes aimed at caries prevention among schoolchildren and free oral healthcare, the caries prevalence remains high. No consistent national oral health school-based promotion programmes have been implemented in Saudi Arabia. From 1993 to 2018, the Ministry of Health has been implementing various school-based oral health programmes. However, no research determines the extent of the changes that have occurred, nor has it evaluated the feasibility, facilitators, barriers, impact, or outcomes of these programmes. Furthermore, none of the programmes included a supervised toothbrushing intervention. Therefore, this study aims to address this research gap by assessing the feasibility of implementing supervised toothbrushing and oral health education programmes, as well as identifying the facilitators and barriers to implementation. While supervised toothbrushing has proven effective in other countries, it remains unclear whether such a programme is transferable and acceptable within the Saudi context. The study specifically seeks to determine the acceptability of the programme among teachers and students, assess willingness to participate among children and their parents, and explore the capacity of schoolteachers to supervise daily toothbrushing sessions. To enhance the oral health of Saudi children, it is important to assess which of the oral health programmes are needed and applicable to the Saudi community, as well as determine the best approach for implementation. Promoting oral health through evidence-based programmes in primary schools may be highly correlated with improving oral health outcomes for this population and acquiring behaviours that are crucial to maintaining optimal oral health throughout life. Aim and Objectives The objectives are: 1. To assess the feasibility of implementing supervised toothbrushing and oral health education programmes in primary schools in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia 2. To identify facilitators and barriers to the implementation, focusing on the programme acceptance, school staff participation, and adherence to the supervision guide 3. To determine the impact of programmes on students' self-reported oral health status, risk behaviour, and quality of life 4. To examine the impact of the programmes on plaque and gingival health status 5. To evaluate the impact of the programmes on dental caries incidence