This study evaluates and compares the clinical and radiographic outcomes of Rosmarinus officinalis and Mineral Trioxide Aggregate (MTA) when used as pulpotomy medicaments in vital mature permanent teeth with irreversible pulpitis. The aim is to determine the effectiveness of both materials in terms of pain reduction and periapical healing. While MTA is considered a gold standard, it has limitations such as high cost, long setting time, and potential discoloration. Therefore, this study investigates Rosmarinus officinalis as a natural, cost-effective alternative with comparable therapeutic potential. This study also provide an alternative to RCT in teeth with irreversible pulpitis
Traditionally, teeth with irreversible pulpitis have been treated either by root canal therapy or extraction, yet root canal treatment, although considered the gold standard, still presents limitations because it is technique-sensitive, invasive, time-consuming, and costly. To address these issues, more affordable and minimally invasive alternatives are being explored. With better understanding of the regenerative and healing abilities of inflamed pulp, along with the development of biologically active materials, vital pulp therapy is now increasingly viewed as a suitable alternative for managing irreversible pulpitis. Mineral trioxide aggregate is widely accepted as the current gold standard, but its drawbacks-including high cost, extended setting time and potential tooth discoloration-remain significant concerns. As a result, newer materials are being evaluated that are more cost-effective while avoiding these disadvantages. One such material, Rosmarinus officinalis, has been used in vital pulp therapy of primary molars and has shown promising results. Despite the documented antimicrobial and anti-inflammatory properties of R. officinalis, its use as a pulpotomy agent in permanent teeth with irreversible pulpitis has not yet been investigated. This study aims to compare the outcomes of pulpotomy treatment using R. officinalis extract both clinically and radiographically versus MTA. This may help provide an alternative to RCT and a more economical option than MTA, while aiming for comparable effectiveness and addressing the limitations associated with MTA. Healthy young adults exhibiting signs and symptoms of irreversible pulpitis in at least one permanent posterior tooth, showing no periapical radiolucency in a periapical x-ray, along with the absence of swelling or sinus tract formation will be selected. Only the teeth with hemostasis achieved following the removal of coronal pulp will be included. A randomized control trail will be conducted, wherein participants will be randomly assigned, using lottery method, to two groups, each consisting of 50 individuals of age 18-40 years of both sexes. After administration of anesthesia and isolation using a rubber dam, a sterile diamond round bur in a high-speed handpiece with water spray will used to remove enamel caries and carbide round bur in slow speed handpiece is used to remove dentinal caries. After the access opening, the coronal pulp will be removed up to the level of the canal orifice using a spoon excavator. After rinsing with sterile saline, hemostasis will be achieved by placing damp cotton soaked in saline. For group A, cotton will be dipped in R-officinalis extract, and placed over radicular pulp for 5 minutes and the pulp chamber will be sealed with a thick paste of aqueous R. officinalis extract with zinc oxide powder and for group B, white MTA will be prepared according to the manufacturer's instructions and placed in the pulp chamber compacted with a damp cotton pellet. Both will be restored with glass ionomer followed by direct composite. An immediate post-op periapical x-ray will be exposed. For clinical and radiographical evaluation patients will be recalled for follow-up at 1 week, 3 month and 6 months. Statistical analysis will be performed at the significance level of p= 0.05.
Study Type
INTERVENTIONAL
Allocation
RANDOMIZED
Purpose
TREATMENT
Masking
DOUBLE
Enrollment
100
MTA shall be mixed according to the manufacturer's instructions (PD SWISS). After achieving a creamy mixture, MTA shall be delivered to the pulp chamber using an amalgam carrier to a 1-2mm thickness. Using a moist pellet, it will be condensed gently over the exposed pulp stumps. Once an initial set of MTA is achieved, the access cavity shall be restored with a glass ionomer cement and composite restoration.
A sterile cotton pellet dipped and squeezed in 6.25% aqueous extract of R-officinalis will be placed over the radicular pulp for 5 minutes. Then, the pulp chamber will be sealed with a thick paste aqueous extract of R. officinalis and zinc oxide powder. The access cavity shall be restored with glass ionomer cement and a composite restoration.
Punjab Dental Hospital, Lahore .
Lahore, Punjab Province, Pakistan
Pain After Intervention, Tenderness to palpation, percussion , Swelling
The incidence and intensity of pain will be assessed postoperatively using the Visual Analogue scale. Pain intensity will be noted as no pain (0-4mm), mild pain (5-44), moderate pain (45-74mm) and severe pain (75-100mm) on a scale of 0-100mm
Time frame: Preop Post op after 1 week, 1month 3 month 6 month
Periapical status after intervention
The periapical status will be assessed by using the periapical index \[PAI\] scoring system. Each tooth will be assigned to one of the PAI scores for the 5 categories within the scale. PAI less than or equal to 2 would be successful outcome. 1. Normal periapical structures 2. Small changes in bone structures 3. Changes in bone structure with mineral loss 4. Periodontitis with well-defined radiolucent area 5. Severe periodontitis with exacerbating features
Time frame: Preop Post op 3 month 6 month
This platform is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare professional.